@nálô: I’ve boycotted most of the big brands anyway. (Except Pampers, which I started buying now). Consciously or unconsciously, not for reasons like this though. For destroying nature, small business and generally asocial practices. Not for their woke-catering marketing. Imo thats not big enough an issue compared to the real shit they also practice.
Its annoying, yes, but come on if thats what it needs fir people to boycott, we may have huge priority issues.
"Enlightenment is man's emergence from his self-imposed nonage. Nonage is the inability to use one's own understanding without another's guidance. This nonage is self-imposed if its cause lies not in lack of understanding but in indecision and lack of courage to use one's own mind without another's guidance. Dare to know! (Sapere aude.) "Have the courage to use your own understanding," is therefore the motto of the enlightenment."
The Simpsons and Family Guy Will Also Recast Their Black Characters With Black Actors
Quote:
The animation industry is currently going through a small reckoning as it finally, finally, really, finally seems to realize that its characters of color could be voiced by actors of color just as easily as white ones.
According to Entertainment Weekly, The Simpsons is the latest animated show to make the change. Earlier this year, Hank Azaria finally stepped away from his role as the Indian character Apu after much criticism, and now the show will recast the entirety of its Black cast as well, including Carl Carlson, Lou, and Dr. Hibbert.
In a statement, producers of the show didn’t do much to elaborate on anything, just saying, “Moving forward, The Simpsons will no longer have white actors voice non-white characters.” Fair enough.
Family Guy is also doing some recasting, with actor Mike Henry stepping away from the role of Cleveland Brown. “I love this character, but persons of color should play characters of color,” he wrote on Twitter. “Therefore, I will be stepping down from the role.”
Which, again, great. It’s wonderful to see white people learn from mistakes and try to do better in the future, even if it’s just on some cartoons. Though the speed at which all these roles have been recast has the rough vibe of people doing something they knew was questionable until the very moment they realized they could no longer ignore criticisms. After all, it’s not like these issues went unremarked-upon until two weeks ago, y’know?
Now that that’s settled, then, maybe these major media properties can use their clout and money to help us defund the police.
So now you don't just need to do a grate voice, your skin color has to match the fictional character you are voicing.
Hulu has removed an episode of sitcom classic “The Golden Girls” containing a scene with characters with mud packs on their faces.
The third season episode, titled “Mixed Feelings” sees Michael (Scott Jacoby), the son of Dorothy (Beatrice Author), planning to wed much older black woman Lorraine (Rosalind Cash). Dorothy is critical of their age difference, while Lorraine’s family disapproves of their daughter marrying a white man.
As Lorraine’s family arrives, Rose (Betty White) and Blanche (Rue McClanahan) are testing out a new mud face treatment and greet the family with their masks still on, saying to them “This is mud on our faces, we’re not really Black.”
The episode is all about skewering pre-conceived notions. Another scene sees Sophia asking Lorraine’s family “Is it true what they say about black men in bed?”. Dorothy admonishes her mother for believing a stereotype, but one of the in-laws replies: “Call it what you want, honey. I’m just glad it’s true.”
Eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeh debatable if cancel culture will have a Streisand effect. When faux morals are at play - it won't do shit. It's a case by case. And mostly on social media platforms.
When louis ck got cancelled. His comedy specials didnt see an uptick of sales.
Hardcore fans will probably rewatch for a laugh - but normal folk not so much. Too much effort to look for something that's banned and inaccessible.
Using this logic, Bart Simpson should then be voiced by a man, not a woman, because it's sexist.
Give it time, it will turn around again. At a certain point, a new show (let's call it The Thompsons or North Park) will show up making fun of all these clichés, becoming hugely popular, and it will shift again.
When people don't learn from history, they tend to repeat it.
Nothing is banned, the streaming services, etc. took down the episodes mostly because the creators of the shows asked them to. There is no law that forbids you to watch these episodes. They also won't be removed from DVD's etc. you can bet your ass on that, lol.
I also think, that most of the removed episodes will come back rather quickly, especially those from comedies, where it's hard to make a case for racism, rather than... comedy...
The Scrubs episodes were taken down at the request of Bill Lawrence, the actual creator. Not from outside pressure. Disney wasn't even considering it. It was Bill alone.
And when people asked him "why not just edit those segments out", he said that we are in a pandemic right now, in case it wasn't obvious. So it's just a matter of time.
And if you want to hear what the actual creators and actors have to say about it, instead of listening/reading ideologues, don't hesitate. The latest episode of their rewatch-podcast was dedicated to this very subject.
"Self-censorship is a lie to yourself; if you are going to be trying to seriously create art, to create literary art, and you decide to hold back, to censor yourself, then you are a fool to yourself and it would be better that you kept your mouth shut and did not speak."
Yeah, that's one opinion. Bill Lawrence has a different opinion on the matter. He is perfectly free to do whatever he wants with what he created. Just as George Lucas was perfectly free to fuck with Star Wars.
Its okay to call yourself a Woman even if you arent one - infact, its really bad if you dont accept one claiming so...but god damn if you try to do be a voiceactor playing another race or similar.
shitloads of new stuff in my pc. Cant keep track of it all.
If your logic is that a less pigmented person cannot play a more pigmented person or vice versa, than that means you're the one acknowledging the race difference. Who is the raycis again?
There are no races. So why can't a person act whoever other person they wish? It doesn't make sense.
Same for men and women. Who cares what gender/sex/fluency the person behind the picture has? If the illusion works, its ok, no?
If anything, the writing could be seen as racist. Debatable case by case.
I like Serdar Somuncus stance on comedy: "Every minority deserves to be made fun of."
"Enlightenment is man's emergence from his self-imposed nonage. Nonage is the inability to use one's own understanding without another's guidance. This nonage is self-imposed if its cause lies not in lack of understanding but in indecision and lack of courage to use one's own mind without another's guidance. Dare to know! (Sapere aude.) "Have the courage to use your own understanding," is therefore the motto of the enlightenment."
Last edited by couleur on Mon, 29th Jun 2020 16:39; edited 1 time in total
Yeah, that's one opinion. Bill Lawrence has a different opinion on the matter. He is perfectly free to do whatever he wants with what he created. Just as George Lucas was perfectly free to fuck with Star Wars.
Well yeah, sure. But that's the horrible idea behind self-censorship, isn't it?
That you aren't even forced to censor your own creations, but you do it out of 'free will'. But it just means the thought police has won.
Shall he also return his royalties/payments he received for his initial creation?
Its okay to call yourself a Woman even if you arent one - infact, its really bad if you dont accept one claiming so...but god damn if you try to do be a voiceactor playing another race or similar.
Black voice actors/actors dont actually mind if white people voice black characters. They just dont want to be overlooked. Because it sets a bad precedent. And it can be challenged. Theres a few black voice actors that voice non black characters and they could be thrown out as well.
The people who mind dont understand the casting process. And the white people jumping ship are causing a problem for the future of voice actors.
Theres a movement within black voice actors that the right person for the job should be hired, not based on race. Because in the end its a cartoon. Once you make it about race - the talent pool shrinks. And many possible jobs will be removed cause the bame voice actor they want is working on another show. And so that role will be reduced or even if its a headline role - the show may not continue production.
So its very interesting. The left is judging people based on the colour of their skin.which is what they're fighting against. Future of animation is at stake and we may not even get dubs anymore \o/.
Was watching 'Moscow on the Hudson' yesterday. It gave me a bit more chuckles this time around than when I first saw it. Just because of the things that would 'upset' people these days.
Got me wondering if Robin Williams would be 'cancelled' these days if he'd still be alive.
And what about voice imitators? They are allowed only to imitate people of their own color now?
The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
Black lives dont matter if its Black on Black crime
Just like white lives dont matter if its white on white crime.
BLM is about racism, police brutality against the blacks, banks denying loans to black people, companies not employing black people. You know complete racism. Fighting for the oppressed. Since blacks dont go to schools. Dont have careers. Are never seen on television/big screen. Theres no black characters in video games. No black authors. No black comedians.
There's no black rich folk.
They're all in the back of the bus.
Y'know. They're fighting for what they already have but at the same time don't have.
there's slavery still in the world. A lot of black folk in america aren't even descendants of slaves. But that is neither here or there. If the mainstream media states that cops only kill black people - then cops only kill black people. If twitter mob says there's disproportion in employment and blacks don't get hired and are left out on the curb - then blacks are never given the opportunity and are never hired ever.
/s
On a real note. Racism does exist and is very real. But we only see a smidge of it. Everything else that's happening now is based on misinformation, feelings and complete ignorance. So faux-racism. And that's the driving force of it. And it's a difficult subject to talk about if you're white - because we simply don't understand it and never will. Because reasons.
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum