*!* What do you think of the moderation on the forums?
Page 3 of 7 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next
Ispep
VIP Member



Posts: 4117

PostPosted: Wed, 11th May 2005 20:55    Post subject:
1. Moderation should be silent. I don't want to hear what you've done - so if your going to delete 4 pages of protection nonsense, just do it, don't inform me. The same goes for the implementation of Templates - which I appreciate - great idea whoevers it was.

2. Moderators should be aware of the personalities on the forum to make a better assessment in regards to banning (etc) - for example I cannot comprehend for the life of me why you would ban AnimalMother for his little outburst (in reaction to Fisk's wonderfully poised party trick). It's just not consistent as he's pointed out - and consistency should be key, along with making some concessions towards the more active members if only because they deserve it.

3. I personally think there are too many moderators in numbers, but I don't know how much or little they do - only the admins have access to that information - so it's their judgement not mine. If they appear to be having an influence on the forum; so be it! It just looks like a lot of mods to me, and this is actually a relatively small forum at the end of the day.

This forum used to be great, and a lot more lenient - I think it's kind of tailed off over time and we had to put up with loads of nonsense relating to protection schemes, flamers and generally just morons who contributed nothing.

What's happened of late is good, but I don't want it to take over, I don't want it to become super strict otherwise it can take away from the 'feeling' of the forum. Don't become anal retentive in your pursuit for the best forum basically. I've been on other forums where this becomes a goal and it just sucks the life out of everyone.

But that's my opinion.

I still think it's a great forum with great characters and as long as we are allowed to continue expressing our opinions on this forum I'm sure it'll continue in that vein. Been a bit rocky lately is all.


Back to top
Sublime




Posts: 8615

PostPosted: Thu, 12th May 2005 02:24    Post subject:
1. Moderation should be silent. I don't want to hear what you've done - so if your going to delete 4 pages of protection nonsense, just do it, don't inform me. The same goes for the implementation of Templates - which I appreciate - great idea whoevers it was.



i've been saying the same thing Razor did it once but then that's it. its just pointless because they do "edited by blah blah" but they post again and say i deleted blah blah immediately after.


Stealth88 and Lod|_Dod| wrote:
"And the winner is.... Sublime!" That fucking kid is always right. Sublime FTW!

http://artpad.art.com/?irqy7s4162w <3 you too
Back to top
Voodoo-child
VIP Member



Posts: 1502
Location: Belgium
PostPosted: Thu, 12th May 2005 16:15    Post subject:
Sublime wrote:
1. Moderation should be silent. I don't want to hear what you've done - so if your going to delete 4 pages of protection nonsense, just do it, don't inform me. The same goes for the implementation of Templates - which I appreciate - great idea whoevers it was.

i've been saying the same thing Razor did it once but then that's it. its just pointless because they do "edited by blah blah" but they post again and say i deleted blah blah immediately after.


It's a way of showing responsibility. We don't want to end up as in
"omfg who edited/deleted this post".

Then again I delete a lot of posts without notifying it
It depends on the situation
Back to top
ApeX PredatoR
VIP Member



Posts: 1951
Location: Los Netherlandos
PostPosted: Thu, 12th May 2005 16:26    Post subject:
I usually post that I've deleted posts so that the one that posted them knows I've deleted them and that he can complain to me if he feels like it, that's why I do it. (Is that a good sentence?)

If people don't like that I we can stop doing that. I'll have to think about that one Wink

I've posted this thread so that I can learn if people think we're too strict or not. This far I'm getting great input. I sure hope expressing your opinion freely here is what you guys continue to do.
Balancing between being lenient and strict is not easy, but I'm sure we'll find the perfect mixture


Injurious wrote:
And then Mabel tripped over a rock and landed in a well and was trapped there with Timmy. Sadly I shot Lassie so no one is saving that bitch!
Back to top
Sublime




Posts: 8615

PostPosted: Thu, 12th May 2005 18:35    Post subject:
i reported it loadsa times though. and you can just edit the last persons post in red and large and say sumthin like EDITED BY APEX, IVE DELETED ALL THE CRAPPY POSTS KEEP IT CLEAN. i'm sure every1 would notice.

I don't see the difference too Confused

why should I edit the last post instead of making a post? Do you think that I'm doing this just to keep my postcount up?


Stealth88 and Lod|_Dod| wrote:
"And the winner is.... Sublime!" That fucking kid is always right. Sublime FTW!

http://artpad.art.com/?irqy7s4162w <3 you too
Back to top
AnimalMother




Posts: 12390
Location: England
PostPosted: Thu, 12th May 2005 19:24    Post subject:
Well I for one like to know whats happend to mine or others posts.

I remember going into a thread and seeing that my post along with a few others had been deleted, but the moderator who had done it let us know, so all was ok. If he hadn't I would have wondered what the hell happend.


"Techniclly speaking, Beta-Manboi didnt inject Burberry_Massi with Benz, he injected him with liquid that had air bubbles in it, which caused benz." - House M.D

"Faith without logic is the same as knowledge without understanding; meaningless"
Back to top
Sublime




Posts: 8615

PostPosted: Thu, 12th May 2005 19:31    Post subject:
but there's no need to make a whole new post. u can still read huge red writing Rolling Eyes


Stealth88 and Lod|_Dod| wrote:
"And the winner is.... Sublime!" That fucking kid is always right. Sublime FTW!

http://artpad.art.com/?irqy7s4162w <3 you too
Back to top
$ilent$uicide




Posts: 252

PostPosted: Thu, 12th May 2005 19:35    Post subject:
In a nut shell: This is the BEST i have ever seen this forum function, dont change a thing.

P.S. Im really digging the new template format, good job! Wink


Windows 7|Enermax1100w|ASUS Rampage III X58|Core i7 990X@ 4.5G|DDR3 3X 2 Mushkin @ 1850mhz |A-Data 256mb SSD|Asus 16X dvd |Nvidia 580XT|Dell Ultrasharp 2405 24" LCD|Creative X-Fi|Logitec Z-680
Back to top
AnimalMother




Posts: 12390
Location: England
PostPosted: Thu, 12th May 2005 19:51    Post subject:
Sublime wrote:
but there's no need to make a whole new post. u can still read huge red writing Rolling Eyes


Who cares if it's a new post or an edit, I don't really see how that matters.


"Techniclly speaking, Beta-Manboi didnt inject Burberry_Massi with Benz, he injected him with liquid that had air bubbles in it, which caused benz." - House M.D

"Faith without logic is the same as knowledge without understanding; meaningless"
Back to top
nouseforaname
Über-VIP Member



Posts: 21306
Location: Toronto, Canada
PostPosted: Thu, 12th May 2005 21:08    Post subject:
I think the moderation is fine, if not a little too strict. I think some degree of flaming should be allowed. I'm not talking about an all out flame-fest... rather a little leniency in determining what exactly is a flame.

I think "Try reading the whole post next time jackass." isn't really that much of a flame. Nor is sometimes stating the obvious fact that some idiot/racist/12 year old/retard/noob is a complete fucktard.


asus z170-A || core i5-6600K || geforce gtx 970 4gb || 16gb ddr4 ram || win10 || 1080p led samsung 27"
Back to top
Godlikez*
Banned



Posts: 2722
Location: In Your Illusions
PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 10:56    Post subject:
AnimalMother wrote:
AnimalMother wrote:


Try reading the whole post next time jackass.


Can't believe I was temp banned for that. I wouldn't mind if the moderation was consistant, but when you get people calling each other inbred fuckers and niggers and they don't get temp banned it hardly seems fair.


Unfortunantly I would probably agree that getting temp banned for that was quite low, I myself noticed you were banned then traced it as a possibility in this thread.....the mod who did that gets a thumbs down from me for not acting on the other user


Daz99 wrote:
Will I get banned for posting a horse and a nakkid black man?

Godlikez* A Proud Muslim Through And Through.
FCC 4 LIYFE [FAT CAT CREW]
 Spoiler:
 
Back to top
[sYn]
[Moderator] Elitist



Posts: 8374

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 12:43    Post subject:
Ispep wrote:
1. Moderation should be silent. I don't want to hear what you've done - so if your going to delete 4 pages of protection nonsense, just do it, don't inform me. The same goes for the implementation of Templates - which I appreciate - great idea whoevers it was.


I dissagree, for the same reasons already pointed out, we need to know where posts are going and why to save bitching further down the line and more thread disruption. It would get annoying if everytime something was deleted someone came along and said:

"OMG, WTFFF! Whyz my postz GONEW?!!111?!"

Im sure you get the picture Wink!

Ispep wrote:

2. Moderators should be aware of the personalities on the forum to make a better assessment in regards to banning (etc) - for example I cannot comprehend for the life of me why you would ban AnimalMother for his little outburst (in reaction to Fisk's wonderfully poised party trick). It's just not consistent as he's pointed out - and consistency should be key, along with making some concessions towards the more active members if only because they deserve it.


YES! This is what I have been trying to say all along, but you managed to put it in a much better way. The mods should know most of the regualrs personalities by now, or at least there "online persona's" and will realise when we are personally stepping out of line and being angered.

EG. I think most people on the forum realise I can be a little up my own arse about certain things, but I wont ever resort to flaming, even that one time when I got very annoyed in the world headlines section Wink!

Just a little more input..
Back to top
toeffy
VIP Member



Posts: 1501

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 13:27    Post subject:
i don't like the idea of silent modding. people should know and see when we do something...that way they see we do something. there is a lot of silent modding on nforce...that's why people think mods are inactive.


jesus christ was a gangsta rapper. they killed him. he came back and made a platinum album.
Back to top
Ispep
VIP Member



Posts: 4117

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 13:28    Post subject:
Quote:
I dissagree, for the same reasons already pointed out, we need to know where posts are going and why to save bitching further down the line and more thread disruption. It would get annoying if everytime something was deleted someone came along and said:

"OMG, WTFFF! Whyz my postz GONEW?!!111?!"

Im sure you get the picture


Yes I understand the points raised about how silent moderation can have it's drawbacks - but if your too stupid to ascertain where your post went, or forgo the careful deliberation in favour of posting; "OMG, WTFFF! Whyz my postz GONEW?!!111?!" you deserve to have your post deleted yet again and perhaps even warned for your behavior.

Maybe it's a personal preference I fall into - but I just don't like it when I start reading a thread and there are intermissions or big/prominent chunks of text relating to the heroic actions of our fearless moderators.

Nor do I like reading about how so and so should use the template, or that there are errors with the template.

I don't know, for me it's just annoying.


Back to top
[sYn]
[Moderator] Elitist



Posts: 8374

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 14:08    Post subject:
Ispep wrote:
Yes I understand the points raised about how silent moderation can have it's drawbacks - but if your too stupid to ascertain where your post went, or forgo the careful deliberation in favour of posting; "OMG, WTFFF! Whyz my postz GONEW?!!111?!" you deserve to have your post deleted yet again and perhaps even warned for your behavior.

Maybe it's a personal preference I fall into - but I just don't like it when I start reading a thread and there are intermissions or big/prominent chunks of text relating to the heroic actions of our fearless moderators.

Nor do I like reading about how so and so should use the template, or that there are errors with the template.

I don't know, for me it's just annoying.


The thought of exessive control I suppose, knowing that you are being watched, if you make a misstake you could very well be punished or told your wrong. Maybe we simply need to assertain when and where a notification should be used, I do think making a huge post screaming "I DONE THAT" is a little OTT, and intrusive. What you said about templates is true also, people need to stop being so anal about them, if one isnt used maybe a mod should come along and change the post to include it? No "OI WHERE IS THE TEMPLATE" posts etc.. this can also be the case if it is wrong, or tags are incorrectly placed.

There are without doubt some happy mediums here, we just need to find them Smile!


Last edited by [sYn] on Fri, 13th May 2005 14:09; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
ApeX PredatoR
VIP Member



Posts: 1951
Location: Los Netherlandos
PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 14:08    Post subject:
Ispep wrote:
Nor do I like reading about how so and so should use the template, or that there are errors with the template.

I don't know, for me it's just annoying.


In that I think you are right. Those kind of posts should be removed, because they have nothing to do with the topic of the thread.
Not only one guy points out that there's an error in the template, nooooo why don't we all post a message saying that the template has an error. Really annoying.


Injurious wrote:
And then Mabel tripped over a rock and landed in a well and was trapped there with Timmy. Sadly I shot Lassie so no one is saving that bitch!
Back to top
[sYn]
[Moderator] Elitist



Posts: 8374

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 14:10    Post subject:
ApeX PredatoR wrote:
In that I think you are right. Those kind of posts should be removed, because they have nothing to do with the topic of the thread.
Not only one guy points out that there's an error in the template, nooooo why don't we all post a message saying that the template has an error. Really annoying.


Maybe having a template mod is a good plan? someone whose sole job is to look after the threads in each forum to make sure they're neat and to the point.
Back to top
AnimalMother




Posts: 12390
Location: England
PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 14:38    Post subject:
[sYn] wrote:
ApeX PredatoR wrote:
In that I think you are right. Those kind of posts should be removed, because they have nothing to do with the topic of the thread.
Not only one guy points out that there's an error in the template, nooooo why don't we all post a message saying that the template has an error. Really annoying.


Maybe having a template mod is a good plan? someone whose sole job is to look after the threads in each forum to make sure they're neat and to the point.


How boring would that be though. Remember they're not getting payed for this.


"Techniclly speaking, Beta-Manboi didnt inject Burberry_Massi with Benz, he injected him with liquid that had air bubbles in it, which caused benz." - House M.D

"Faith without logic is the same as knowledge without understanding; meaningless"
Back to top
[sYn]
[Moderator] Elitist



Posts: 8374

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 14:38    Post subject:
AnimalMother wrote:
How boring would that be though. Remember they're not getting payed for this.


I was thinking more along the lines of finding someone who wants to do it Razz! Plus I doubt it would be a huge amount of work, lets face it, we dont have that many new release threads, unless it happens to be a busy week, but those dont come around too often!
Back to top
Ispep
VIP Member



Posts: 4117

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 16:20    Post subject:
What I think would be better is if there is somekind of template embedded into the forum itself - so you could actually select it as an option in the post new topic area. Another possibility is an extension for Firefox that automatically pastes all the requried code for you to complete.


Back to top
MAD_MAX333
Moderator



Posts: 7020
Location: Toronto, Canada...eh
PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 16:35    Post subject:
i think that idea is floating around and will be implemented when admins are free from chasing girls around...
Back to top
Voodoo-child
VIP Member



Posts: 1502
Location: Belgium
PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 17:45    Post subject:
Ispep wrote:
What I think would be better is if there is somekind of template embedded into the forum itself - so you could actually select it as an option in the post new topic area. Another possibility is an extension for Firefox that automatically pastes all the requried code for you to complete.


U do realise that's a LOT of scripting :/
Back to top
Ispep
VIP Member



Posts: 4117

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 18:14    Post subject:
What, you want my sympathy?... Very Happy


Back to top
Voodoo-child
VIP Member



Posts: 1502
Location: Belgium
PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 19:08    Post subject:
Ispep wrote:
What, you want my sympathy?... Very Happy


no only your sweet-lovin' :')
Back to top
Pizda2




Posts: 3028

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 19:52    Post subject:
Voodoo-child wrote:
Ispep wrote:
What, you want my sympathy?... Very Happy


no only your sweet-lovin' :')


Hahahahahah
Back to top
Evil Undead Dolphin
Banned



Posts: 226

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 22:54    Post subject:
I think moderators are ok. Really , we have here whats its called FREEDOM OF SPEECH!
Everyone have a right to own opinion (EVEN ME ! Very Happy ) KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!
Back to top
fisk




Posts: 9145
Location: Von Oben
PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 23:16    Post subject:
Evil Undead Dolphin wrote:
I think moderators are ok. Really , we have here whats its called FREEDOM OF SPEECH!
Everyone have a right to own opinion (EVEN ME ! Very Happy ) KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!


Freedom of speech? On a forum? I think not.


Yes, yes I'm back.
Somewhat.
Back to top
Evil Undead Dolphin
Banned



Posts: 226

PostPosted: Fri, 13th May 2005 23:31    Post subject:
fisk wrote:
Evil Undead Dolphin wrote:
I think moderators are ok. Really , we have here whats its called FREEDOM OF SPEECH!
Everyone have a right to own opinion (EVEN ME ! Very Happy ) KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!


Freedom of speech? On a forum? I think not.


Why not? Only NAZI bullshit , cursing , threats are censored so far...
Thats why I went from ISONEWS .....I cant stand those retarded kids..
Back to top
Voodoo-child
VIP Member



Posts: 1502
Location: Belgium
PostPosted: Sat, 14th May 2005 13:55    Post subject:
fisk wrote:
Evil Undead Dolphin wrote:
I think moderators are ok. Really , we have here whats its called FREEDOM OF SPEECH!
Everyone have a right to own opinion (EVEN ME ! Very Happy ) KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!


Freedom of speech? On a forum? I think not.


fisk got a point there, we have all the rights the remove or edit posts as we wish to
Back to top
ApeX PredatoR
VIP Member



Posts: 1951
Location: Los Netherlandos
PostPosted: Tue, 17th May 2005 07:02    Post subject:
Tnx for everyone's input.
I'll read the thread trough again and try to extract some spoints of improvement. I will discuss those with the team.


Injurious wrote:
And then Mabel tripped over a rock and landed in a well and was trapped there with Timmy. Sadly I shot Lassie so no one is saving that bitch!
Back to top
Page 3 of 7 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Site Feedback Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group