|
|
| Page 146 of 179 |
sausje
Banned
Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 12:25 Post subject: |
|
 |
Then you see them use the protos air forces more then enough.
Plus:
| Quote: | Vs. Zerg
Phoenixes are a very common followup after expanding in PvZ, or even as an opening. Generally, Phoenixes are far more effective when waiting for 4 or more before showing them to your opponent because 4 Phoenixes can kill a Queen in one gravitation beam. Phoenixes can be used to bully Overlords off the map to deny scouting, and can even kill them to supply cap the Zerg and potentially deal significant damage. Phoenixes are great in combination with Void Rays, as Phoenixes can lift units, such as Queens, and Void Rays can deal the damage without being attacked. Phoenixes are very deadly to small groups of Zerg units. Even Hydralisks are vulnerable to a few Phoenixes if there are not enough of them. Considering a Hydralisk's slow movement speed, Phoenixes are very hard to deal with for Zerg. Infestors can also be picked off, but great care must be taken when the Infestor has enough energy to Fungal Growth because that could potentially get an entire group of Phoenixes killed. Phoenixes also discourage Mutalisk play, and may force your opponent to make Hydralisks, thus, Colossi are the most common transition after Phoenixes. This also easily sets the Protoss up for the deadly Colossus/Void Ray composition. |
http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/Phoenix#Vs._Zerg
Muta are only 50 minerals cheaper, while Phoenix are more cost effective. 
Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)

|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
JackQ
Non-expret in Derps lagunge
Posts: 14526
Location: Kibbutznik, Israel
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Surray
Posts: 5409
Location: Europe
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 12:35 Post subject: |
|
 |
phoenixes are a horrible counter to mass muta. it works fine in small numbers but once you're dealing with like 20+ mutas you need shitloads of phoenixes and then you're way way too vulnerable to infestors. 1 fungal and it's game over. on the same page, a single wrong click and your phoenixes vaporize if the muta ball gets into range. then you're left with useless stargates as well.
yes, with perfect micro and no fungals they will always win easily, but no one has perfect micro.
the only way to deal with shitloads of mutas are stalkers, archons, and high templar. preferably all of those at once.
and while it's true that you can discourage muta use with just getting a handful (3 or 4) of phoenixes preemptively for scouting and harass, if they do decide to go mutas anyway those phoenixes are not going to be able to do much.
phoenixes just don't work against mass mutas.
Likot Mosuskekim, Woodcutter cancels Sleep: Interrupted by Elephant.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 12:36 Post subject: |
|
 |
HuK uses stargate units rarely. WhiteRa is known to do that more often, however he opts to mix in a couple of void rays with his main army and use phoenix for harrassing ov's and queens in the early game.
"Discouraging" muta play is quite different than acutally countering mass muta with phoenix (rather than, say, blink stalkers, storms and/or archons). You probably know that wiki tactics only go so far.
If this wasn't an issue, they wouldn't have adressed it by bringing in the tempest.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
sausje
Banned
Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 12:43 Post subject: |
|
 |
| Surray wrote: | | phoenixes just don't work against mass mutas. |
They do, but you have to mix in blink stalkers to make them effective, but they are not worthless against mass Muta.
@Prismvg, thats why when i tuned in 3 days ago, he did atleast 3 games in a row with stargate and mass carriers. But what do i know, you seem to think that i'm some kind of retard.
Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)

|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 12:56 Post subject: |
|
 |
And why are you putting words in my mouth, exactly? I was having a civilized conversation, but happened to disagree with you, like others, it would seem.
Regarding his stream, what he does for fun now and then can hardly be considered a style of play or, for that matter, a valid tactic.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
JackQ
Non-expret in Derps lagunge
Posts: 14526
Location: Kibbutznik, Israel
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 13:02 Post subject: |
|
 |
| sausje wrote: | | Surray wrote: | | phoenixes just don't work against mass mutas. |
They do, but you have to mix in blink stalkers to make them effective, but they are not worthless against mass Muta.
|
that what has been said here,they are not counter to mass muta,and you are still forced to use some Psi Storms.
"Fuck Denuvo"
Your personal opinions != the rest of the forum
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Surray
Posts: 5409
Location: Europe
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 13:08 Post subject: |
|
 |
If he was using carriers it's pretty safe to say he was screwing around. No one actually uses carriers competitively because they're horrible.
Phoenixes do decent against mutas if they have support but that defeats the purpose of having them as you have to keep them close to your army, their mobility advantage is pretty much nullified. If you're going to do that you might as well just go for more stalkers, archons and high templar as I said earlier to deal with mutas with your core army. That will give you a stronger and more versatile army.
So while phoenixes are in theory a counter to mutas, they don't actually counter them. They just do ok against them.. like zerglings do ok against marines.. but that's all.
You can't count on phoenixes to save you against mutas in the way that actual counters work, like colossi smashing marines, immortals destroying ultras and stuff like that.
I'm sure blizzard intended them to counter phoenixes but it just didn't work out like that... and they know that.. so now we get the tempest to fix the problem.
Sausje, why are you acting like there is no problem when even blizzard obviously acknowledged it with their addition of the tempest? They said it's clear that protoss needs something to deal with mass mutas, and the tempest is their solution... if it was fine as it is the tempest wouldn't exist.
Likot Mosuskekim, Woodcutter cancels Sleep: Interrupted by Elephant.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 13:21 Post subject: |
|
 |
Imho, phoenixes counter mutas, because battles are not only about unit compositions but also timing. If you open with zealots in to phoenix for example, and the enemy STILL opts to go mutas, you just steamroll him and win right there. No one sane pumps mutas, when there's 4 phoenixes out, and if they do, sure, they will overpower the phoenixes, then promptly lose the game, because they don't have enough gas invested in ground forces.
In 1v1 phoenix play is very, very effective, you just have to be active with them. No point in having them, if you don't constantly use them.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Surray
Posts: 5409
Location: Europe
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 13:25 Post subject: |
|
 |
you're talking about early game stuff, radicalus.
as you said, no one is crazy enough to go mutas that early because you're too easily killed off. you never see that against protoss.
what this is all about is mass muta later in the game
if you build 20 phoenixes to deal with 40 mutas you must be suicidal.
Likot Mosuskekim, Woodcutter cancels Sleep: Interrupted by Elephant.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 13:36 Post subject: |
|
 |
By end game, as protoss, I usually have a force of around 8 archons, and constantly attack, which means they can't afford to 1. build mutas or 2. go off harassing with them. Of course, this is a problem, in the sense, that if you don't constantly play aggressive, you'll lose, and a strategy game should be about choices. But that's it.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
sausje
Banned
Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 13:36 Post subject: |
|
 |
Unless one of us, is in grand master, nobody knows the hows or what and we are all noobs as this. (even tho as High Diamond 1's, im prolly highest ranked here ^_^, back in first season, now i barely play.)
No point having discussions about this, its the same as having discussions about classes in MMORPG's.
1 thinks this is best, while the other one thinks the opposide, both are right on a few fronts but 1 side can never be fully right.
So lets just leave it here 
Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)

|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 13:48 Post subject: |
|
 |
Just because I'm not grandmaster, doesn't mean I understand the game less than a grandmaster. My limiting factor, the reason, why I don't get above high diamond, is because I don't have the mechanics nor the motivation to get better mechanics. I understand the game fine enough to comment.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
sausje
Banned
Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 13:53 Post subject: |
|
 |
That's what they all say about all games 
Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)

|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 13:59 Post subject: |
|
 |
That's pretty much fact in my case with sc2. I'm comfortable at the level I am, because getting here took little effort and little practice, however from here upwards it's a game of diminishing returns, and for me, gaming is not that important, I have a company to lead and I want to start my PhD next year, so yeah, I'm not motivated.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Sin317
Banned
Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 14:04 Post subject: |
|
 |
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
sausje
Banned
Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 14:07 Post subject: |
|
 |
Sin, its no point, they dont understand that.
Just because they view video's, watch strategies and play a little themselfs, they even DARE to say that they are on equal knowledge of the game as the pro's.
Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)

|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Sin317
Banned
Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 14:14 Post subject: |
|
 |
We can agree to disagree. I for one think, that one can have deep enough understanding of a game to comment on balance, without having to be in the top 100 players. My main limit is inability to multitask at mid-end game, because there's so much I know I want to do, but can't, so my timing slips, but I understand perfectly well, what I should do.
Let's be serious here, understanding a strategy game is understanding a somewhat complex relation network of causes and effects, you can do that perfectly, without being able to actually play the game realtime.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 14:15 Post subject: |
|
 |
| sausje wrote: | Sin, its no point, they dont understand that.
Just because they view video's, watch strategies and play a little themselfs, they even DARE to say that they are on equal knowledge of the game as the pro's. |
Give me arguments, why theoretically someone, who doesn't play at the level of professionals, can't understand the game on the level, that professionals do. I await your arguments. No straw men please.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
sausje
Banned
Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 14:25 Post subject: |
|
 |
No, i wont. Because its futile against people like you.
You would contradict EVERY point i would make, even if they are strongly underbuilded.
Its just no point, so i wont even bother starting it.
Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)

|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 14:35 Post subject: |
|
 |
| sausje wrote: | No, i wont. Because its futile against people like you.
You would contradict EVERY point i would make, even if they are strongly underbuilded.
Its just no point, so i wont even bother starting it. |
Futile against people like me? You mean people who'd actually let arguments decide claims?
I mean, how else do YOU know, that you are right in this question, if you don't want to test out your arguments against other arguments, that carry within themselves the possibility of refuting yours'?
You claimed it's ridiculous, that some people DARE claim they have an equal understanding of a game as people who are best at said game. I simply ask, what theoretical reason there is, why someone couldn't potentially understand the game as well as those who play it best?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
JackQ
Non-expret in Derps lagunge
Posts: 14526
Location: Kibbutznik, Israel
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 15:01 Post subject: |
|
 |
I don't believe anyone claim about their rank until Source for this.
"Fuck Denuvo"
Your personal opinions != the rest of the forum
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 16:32 Post subject: |
|
 |
why someone couldn't potentially understand the game as well as those who play it best?
lets say we meet in a quake 3 game.
5 years ago, using my old boomslang ball mouse (i had it since 2000, and yes, ball mouse), i could stlll reach a 100% accuaracy with rail gun (main weapon i use), an get perfect control of any map, knowing the exact time for armor/weapon spawn and powerups (usually we play with them disabled).
if you canot reach that level in knowing the game, you canot have any talk about balancing a map, weapons and/or powerups.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 17:56 Post subject: |
|
 |
What about if someone also knows how you play, and how one can play at the top of their game, and analyze that data as well as the data they know about the game? There's no reason for this not being possible ... in fact:
Why do top sc2 players need coaching (usually by their teammates)? Well, even day9 admits, that learning a strategy game happens between play sessions. Why is that? Because that's when you can truly analyze your play, the enemy's play and the game. Also, players, when watching their own replays, tend to still have emotional ties to the choices they made in game, and often can't admit making a wrong choice, I see this happening day to day as a trainer in the civil society sphere, where I often have to analyze and work on leaders' decision making and communication.
It is much easier to understand relations, when you have nothing invested in them, because only then can you reach objectivity.
Take Idra for example. One of the best players, no one would question that, yet he claimed very often, that something is imbalanced, only for a few days/weeks to pass, and voila, players found ways around the perceived problem, and it turned out, that it was Idra, who was wrong all along by not being objective enough.
Let me give you another example: you can easily reach diamond by using various forms of cheese of a single race, does that mean, that overall that person would have deeper understanding of the game as a whole than someone who's in gold, but plays random and plays macro games? The cheeser understands the first 10 minutes of the game very well, if everything happens according to his plan, but the gold player understands a lot more relations, he just can't put them in practice.
There simply is no theoretical reason, why someone could completely and utterly understand any system, just because they don't have first hand experience within the system. Guys, science is all about understanding systems and correlations, without actually having to be in them.
If someone has good analytic skills and does a proper job of investigating any system (like game balance), then he can reach a level of knowledge on parity with that of a professional player's.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
sausje
Banned
Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 19:39 Post subject: |
|
 |
See, its no point. EVERYTHING you say, no matter how good your arguements are, will be wrong in his eyes.
Best to ignore and forget about him.
That's what I'm doing now.
Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)

|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 19:56 Post subject: |
|
 |
Have I offended you with something Sausje? Because, last I checked, this was a forum, you know, where you have to back up your claims with some points, which you failed to do to begin with. Of course, it's easy to be the victor, when you shut out any source of challenging opinions. I've put my opinions out there for all to scrutinize, all you did was claim something, then not back it up, saying it's futile, because *gulp* there'll be someone, who might disagree.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 20:15 Post subject: |
|
 |
If someone has good analytic skills and does a proper job of investigating any system (like game balance), then he can reach a level of knowledge on parity with that of a professional player's.
this thing is not true for any profesion/hobby/whatever.
i dont even know where to start to explain this to you, is like 2+2=4.
is like average joe knowing chess, and explaining strategy to kasparov.
is like you knowing all poker theoryes, and claim that you will teach cada a few lessons.
is like you know how to make a complicated cooking recipe (hey, you have the recipe), and claim that you will do it and will taste like a pro chief one.
if you dont do things at "pro" level, dont talk like you know how is like at that level.
no matter the domain.
how do you hit with rail gun always ?
well, aim and shot, is not that hard.
the truth is, that is really hard.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
JackQ
Non-expret in Derps lagunge
Posts: 14526
Location: Kibbutznik, Israel
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 20:22 Post subject: |
|
 |
explain me why if there is no balance problems,why it's more hard to counter Zerg,then the other races?
they have the best chance to win rush,if you don't block off your base as other race for zergling and roaches in the start,it's GG for you,in roaches is worst,cuz the rush don't hurt the Zerg player economy like Zergling one the same can't be said for other races,you don't need to block off your base as terran vs toss,although it's recommended.
not the mention Mutas,they are worst then DT and Banshee,cuz they are coming at big Numbers,eliminating your workers and escaping,as protoss it's very hard cuz cannons are expensive and make your gameplay more passive, you are forced somewhat to play "cat and mouse" with mutas,with stalkers,and with Phoenix,the Zerg just creating more mutas and Phoenix becoming kinda useless.
"Fuck Denuvo"
Your personal opinions != the rest of the forum
Last edited by JackQ on Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 20:27; edited 1 time in total
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Sin317
Banned
Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
|
Posted: Sat, 22nd Oct 2011 20:26 Post subject: |
|
 |
| JackQ wrote: | explain me why if there is no balance problems,why it's more hard to counter Zerg,then the other races?
they have the best chance to win rush,if you don't block off your base as other race for zergling and roaches in the start,it's GG for you,in roaches is worst,cuz the rush don't hurt the Zerg player economy like Zergling one the same can't be said for other races,you don't need to block off your base as terran vs toss,although it's recommended. |
perfect example of a low skilled player lol.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
| Page 146 of 179 |
All times are GMT + 1 Hour |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
|
|
 |
|