The Hobbit (2010)
Page 20 of 20 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 18, 19, 20
me7




Posts: 3949

PostPosted: Sun, 27th Oct 2013 12:02    Post subject:
chiv wrote:
extended editions are basically for the filmmakers to put in everything they WANTED to put in to tell the story.

often that stuff, while good and providing enhancement to the story, doesnt flow as nicely as a complete film, or maybe makes the pace slow down a bit too much, and the decision is made that the ADD crowds out there will be turned off by it... its still interesting stuff that provides depth to the story, but it just doesnt sit as well as other stuff does, so it gets removed. remember, the theatre is where these films make most of their money, so its what needs to be sacrifices to make as much profit as it can.



anyway back to the movie... 13 minutes is a bit of a disappointment... i was hopping for more. either its just a cash grab, or the filmmakers actually ended up with the majority of the film intact.


At the end of the day, it's a short 300-page book turned into three lengthy films. I haven't read it, but I don't think there is much opportunity to leave things out in the first place.
All three extended versions will probably have rather small additions.
Back to top
chiv




Posts: 27530
Location: Behind You...
PostPosted: Sun, 27th Oct 2013 12:46    Post subject:
not really a fair argument...

thats like saying a movie based on a short story (of which there are a fair few) has no right to be more than 30 minutes long. the book was an outline... a starting point from which they built on and fleshed out a larger story. As long as they key plot points are there in the film, anything else in between is totally up to the filmmakers creativity and freedom, as long as its in keeping with the tolkien universe.


Back to top
Stormwolf




Posts: 24747
Location: Norway
PostPosted: Sun, 27th Oct 2013 15:30    Post subject:
Well, at least they added some nice scenes. I enjoyed the extended edition.
Back to top
zibz
Banned



Posts: 556

PostPosted: Sun, 27th Oct 2013 15:46    Post subject:
Saner wrote:
Look YIFI are top quality, if they say its 48 then it is obviously 128



Aww Yeah
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8281
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Sun, 27th Oct 2013 21:19    Post subject:
me7 wrote:


At the end of the day, it's a short 300-page book turned into three lengthy films. I haven't read it, but I don't think there is much opportunity to leave things out in the first place.
All three extended versions will probably have rather small additions.

Doesn't The Hobbit end with the second movie? I thought the third movie will be about historic events from the Silmarillion and/or mentioned in the Lord of the Rings.

I'm actually looking more forward to the third movie if this is indeed so Very Happy
Back to top
consolitis
VIP Member



Posts: 27317

PostPosted: Sun, 27th Oct 2013 21:31    Post subject:
Il_Padrino wrote:
me7 wrote:


At the end of the day, it's a short 300-page book turned into three lengthy films. I haven't read it, but I don't think there is much opportunity to leave things out in the first place.
All three extended versions will probably have rather small additions.

Doesn't The Hobbit end with the second movie? I thought the third movie will be about historic events from the Silmarillion and/or mentioned in the Lord of the Rings.

I'm actually looking more forward to the third movie if this is indeed so Very Happy


Impossible, they don't have the rights to it.

The third film will be enriched by stuff written in the appendices of lotr3, but it will basically be the final part of the Hobbit book story, not a new adventure.


TWIN PEAKS is "something of a miracle."
"...like nothing else on television."
"a phenomenon."
"A tangled tale of sex, violence, power, junk food..."
"Like Nothing On Earth"

~ WHAT THEY'RE TRYING TO SAY CAN ONLY BE SEEN ~

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CHTUOgYNRzY
Back to top
dingo_d
VIP Member



Posts: 14555

PostPosted: Sun, 27th Oct 2013 21:50    Post subject:
I think that the third movie will be about the battle of the five armies, and added stuff from lotr...


"Quantum mechanics is actually, contrary to it's reputation, unbeliveably simple, once you take the physics out."
Scott Aaronson
chiv wrote:
thats true you know. newton didnt discover gravity. the apple told him about it, and then he killed it. the core was never found.

Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75740
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Fri, 1st Nov 2013 23:33    Post subject:
Watching the two extra blurays (the "Appendices"), the part where they flew to London to shoot a very elderly Christoper Lee and Ian Holm just reminded me how much I loved these movies. It is almost impossible for me to believe that so many years have passed by since.


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
dingo_d
VIP Member



Posts: 14555

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Nov 2013 09:53    Post subject:
LeoNatan wrote:
Watching the two extra blurays (the "Appendices"), the part where they flew to London to shoot a very elderly Christoper Lee and Ian Holm just reminded me how much I loved these movies. It is almost impossible for me to believe that so many years have passed by since.


Yeah that what I find myself wondering myself. It was over ten years that fellowship of the ring came out, and still after all this years, lotr trilogy is one of the greatest ever imo.
You can watch it today and still be amazed Smile


"Quantum mechanics is actually, contrary to it's reputation, unbeliveably simple, once you take the physics out."
Scott Aaronson
chiv wrote:
thats true you know. newton didnt discover gravity. the apple told him about it, and then he killed it. the core was never found.

Back to top
Yondaime
VIP Member



Posts: 11740

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Nov 2013 11:31    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by Yondaime on Mon, 2nd Dec 2024 15:38; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Frant
King's Bounty



Posts: 24975
Location: Your Mom
PostPosted: Wed, 10th Feb 2021 18:06    Post subject:
This particular fan edit seems interesting:



Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn!
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Wed, 10th Feb 2021 19:14    Post subject:


Smile
Back to top
WaldoJ
VIP Member



Posts: 32678

PostPosted: Wed, 10th Feb 2021 20:15    Post subject:
Enough with that trash Jesus. Hes a deluded idiot who loves the sound of his voice and his opinions are trash. He lives in his own mind and his opinions are amplified by other dull headed maggots. Simple. All his commentary is cause i said so. Doesnt dissect anything or adds anything of value. All of his opinions are just copy pasta from some random 4chan post made by a 12 year old thinking hes edgy cause he called some people chocolate milk people. Fuck off.

He calls lotr a faithful adaptation and then talks about how it misses a few things and shit. Talks about how he loves the books and the stories and yet misses the point of the hobbit and the movies.

Hobbit sucks cause it didn't have the gritty magic of the lotr trilogy.
Extending it to 3 movies was for profit. Didn't make it worse or anything. Subject matter was shit in the books and in the movies. Simple. Thats why it sucks. The visuals are nice. The effects are nice. The craftsmanship is nice. But the story is shit. They added shit to fluff it out and guess what... shit.


Sin317 wrote:
I win, you lose. Or Go fuck yourself.
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14918
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Wed, 10th Feb 2021 20:42    Post subject:
Nah, love Critical Drinker, not as good as Nerdrotic or HeelvsBabyface but his opinions are usually really solid/common sense stuff.. I don't agree with him here though, i think the Hobbit movies are good, not great, and i dare him or anyone else to find equally good fantasy movies apart from LOTR. There aren't many.

Bilbo's character development is better in the movies than in the book. The two last movies are not as great, but very good pop-corn fantasy that doesn't require a lot from the viewer, far less draining than something like LOTR (also the reason why i've watched these movies more times than LOTR).

Frant wrote:
This particular fan edit seems interesting:


Downloading... making it into 3 movies was a mistake. ONE great movie would have been SO much better. Edit: meh, really low quality (720p i guess), stuttery FPS, unwatchable to me.

Personally i would love to see a russian adaptation, yes, laugh all you want Very Happy something in the spirit of Tarkovsky. Very low-key, way more focus on characters and beauty of nature, more poetic and less CGI overall, way darker.. one thing i don't think the movies does well is overall photo, the last LOTR movie is especially ugly, the lighting looks super artificial, like everything is shot in full sunshine and they've tried their best to make it look darker and grimmer.
Back to top
WaldoJ
VIP Member



Posts: 32678

PostPosted: Wed, 10th Feb 2021 23:26    Post subject:
Nah his opinions are a mishmash of popular comments underneath a youtube video of same subject. He doesn't add anything to the conversation.

His villains video overlooked a plethora of movies that used traditional villains and focused solely on popular pop culture whilst ignoring niche pop culture.

Same goes for a lot of his videos. Focuses on a tiny spec of something as if it were the main aspect. Its just reading comments with a fancy accent.


Sin317 wrote:
I win, you lose. Or Go fuck yourself.
Back to top
Page 20 of 20 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Movie & TV Sparks Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 18, 19, 20
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group