I'll hold of till the end product, but last week I was bitching about how shows and movies are using inferior CGI compared to when they didn't and used scaled models and such.
CGI is only nice when it's high quality, some shows look done by people whom are even worse than some of the lower budget or crap games CGI.
Those last two posts... you are both kidding right?
Depends on. If that retarded muppet show reject is the to promote the movie and not actually be in the movie its ok..
But if it IS in the movie or anything remotely similar..then no.
Maybe you don't get it though, not sure how old you are though with all this but the classic starwars first three films is where it is at... If he has gone back to puppets like back from the first film in the 70's then that is what will make the films great again. CGI is nice yes but to those that remember what a starwars film was this is a godsend returning to those ways.
See myself see the films after the first trilogy a turn for the worse, it was when films in general started going full bore cgi ( of course its the future for visuals ) but it for me does not capture that starwars feeling anymore if its abused.
All you have to do is take a look at the sets being made and the puppet vid above and hope at least for me that the director IS going back to the old visual style which believe me WILL capture the starwars fans imagination again.
If its full of green screens and cgi it will pass as a great action film, but not a great immersive one.
Spoiler:
why the fuck does this forum think immersive is spelt wrong
For example, Guardians of the Galaxy will be great with its cgi etc but would not be great with hand made sets for everything and puppets.
Meh one has to get it to get it and seems maybe there is a lot of younger generations floating around here these days that never got to experience the first hand showings of starwars movies.
Those last two posts... you are both kidding right?
Depends on. If that retarded muppet show reject is the to promote the movie and not actually be in the movie its ok..
But if it IS in the movie or anything remotely similar..then no.
Maybe you don't get it though, not sure how old you are though with all this but the classic starwars first three films is where it is at... If he has gone back to puppets like back from the first film in the 70's then that is what will make the films great again. CGI is nice yes but to those that remember what a starwars film was this is a godsend returning to those ways.
See myself see the films after the first trilogy a turn for the worse, it was when films in general started going full bore cgi ( of course its the future for visuals ) but it for me does not capture that starwars feeling anymore if its abused.
All you have to do is take a look at the sets being made and the puppet vid above and hope at least for me that the director IS going back to the old visual style which believe me WILL capture the starwars fans imagination again.
If its full of green screens and cgi it will pass as a great action film, but not a great immersive one.
Spoiler:
why the fuck does this forum think immersive is spelt wrong
For example, Guardians of the Galaxy will be great with its cgi etc but would not be great with hand made sets for everything and puppets.
Meh one has to get it to get it and seems maybe there is a lot of younger generations floating around here these days that never got to experience the first hand showings of starwars movies.
I saw Star Wars in the 70s. And I never did like puppets. Im 42btw.
shitloads of new stuff in my pc. Cant keep track of it all.
Depends on. If that retarded muppet show reject is the to promote the movie and not actually be in the movie its ok..
But if it IS in the movie or anything remotely similar..then no.
Maybe you don't get it though, not sure how old you are though with all this but the classic starwars first three films is where it is at... If he has gone back to puppets like back from the first film in the 70's then that is what will make the films great again. CGI is nice yes but to those that remember what a starwars film was this is a godsend returning to those ways.
See myself see the films after the first trilogy a turn for the worse, it was when films in general started going full bore cgi ( of course its the future for visuals ) but it for me does not capture that starwars feeling anymore if its abused.
All you have to do is take a look at the sets being made and the puppet vid above and hope at least for me that the director IS going back to the old visual style which believe me WILL capture the starwars fans imagination again.
If its full of green screens and cgi it will pass as a great action film, but not a great immersive one.
Spoiler:
why the fuck does this forum think immersive is spelt wrong
For example, Guardians of the Galaxy will be great with its cgi etc but would not be great with hand made sets for everything and puppets.
Meh one has to get it to get it and seems maybe there is a lot of younger generations floating around here these days that never got to experience the first hand showings of starwars movies.
I saw Star Wars in the 70s. And I never did like puppets. Im 42btw.
ok so we both stood in que with dad for a while and regarding how you never did like puppets back then you only had puppets so what happened to you? You either A) did not like the film at all, or B) something else.
I just dont see you as a young lad watching the first film and thinking that the film was not fantastic - but hey fuck it you have baffled me
Maybe you don't get it though, not sure how old you are though with all this but the classic starwars first three films is where it is at... If he has gone back to puppets like back from the first film in the 70's then that is what will make the films great again. CGI is nice yes but to those that remember what a starwars film was this is a godsend returning to those ways.
See myself see the films after the first trilogy a turn for the worse, it was when films in general started going full bore cgi ( of course its the future for visuals ) but it for me does not capture that starwars feeling anymore if its abused.
All you have to do is take a look at the sets being made and the puppet vid above and hope at least for me that the director IS going back to the old visual style which believe me WILL capture the starwars fans imagination again.
If its full of green screens and cgi it will pass as a great action film, but not a great immersive one.
Spoiler:
why the fuck does this forum think immersive is spelt wrong
For example, Guardians of the Galaxy will be great with its cgi etc but would not be great with hand made sets for everything and puppets.
Meh one has to get it to get it and seems maybe there is a lot of younger generations floating around here these days that never got to experience the first hand showings of starwars movies.
I saw Star Wars in the 70s. And I never did like puppets. Im 42btw.
ok so we both stood in que with dad for a while and regarding how you never did like puppets back then you only had puppets so what happened to you? You either A) did not like the film at all, or B) something else.
I just dont see you as a young lad watching the first film and thinking that the film was not fantastic - but hey fuck it you have baffled me
No, I did like it. But I never did like the obvious puppets.
shitloads of new stuff in my pc. Cant keep track of it all.
CGI was never what was wrong with the 1-3 trilogy, as far as I'm concerned. It was most of everything else
Using puppets is not a bad idea, but has to be done right and somewhat enhanced with CGI when needed. If going back to puppets means having, say, a Yoda-like character that looks, moves and has wooden expresions of his Empire Strikes Back counterpart, then I say: go CGI! It doesn't look good, it doesn't feel good (not for a modern movie, at least) - it would be just retro for the sake of retro and, unless that's what the movie is all about, that's never a good thing.
CGI is a tool, and so are puppets. Every tool should be used when it's needed and to the extent it's needed. Not overused or left aside because of some strange philosphy/ideology.
• Pip Andersen, a British actor with experience in the wall-climbing athletic art of parkour. He was also hired for an unspecified role. Anderson was most recently seen in a Spider-Man promo for Sony.
• Crystal Clarke, an American actress who was studying in Glasgow, Scotland. She has appeared numerous times onstage and will appear in her first feature film next year, The Moon and the Sun. She’ll be inhabiting other celestial bodies in Episode VII, although her character has not been specified.
CGI was never what was wrong with the 1-3 trilogy, as far as I'm concerned. It was most of everything else
Using puppets is not a bad idea, but has to be done right and somewhat enhanced with CGI when needed. If going back to puppets means having, say, a Yoda-like character that looks, moves and has wooden expresions of his Empire Strikes Back counterpart, then I say: go CGI! It doesn't look good, it doesn't feel good (not for a modern movie, at least) - it would be just retro for the sake of retro and, unless that's what the movie is all about, that's never a good thing.
CGI is a tool, and so are puppets. Every tool should be used when it's needed and to the extent it's needed. Not overused or left aside because of some strange philosphy/ideology.
not many actors can act in front of a green screen looking at some invisible monster.
not many vfx studios put a lot of attention to detail when creating cgi.
There's a handful of studios where them creating CGI is akin to using puppets. And there's a whole lot of studios where them creating CGI looks just BAD BAD BAD. Like... they dunno how to track eyes anymore
Also CGI dates badly. Really badly. Spiderman 3... looks BAD now. No idea why Raimi went CGI for it. but it looks BAD.
Look at CGI heavy movies from 10-20-30 years ago. And look at something like OG total recall. Real FX are the best thing to use. Once you go CGI... if you care about your project... then you have to release updated versions of the movie every few years or it will age badly.
CGI is also more expensive at times. But at times it's a lot cheaper than designing a puppet, hiring a puppeteer, building sets. Especially these days.
It just so happens that I recently saw Terminator 2 and I can honestly say CGI in that movie hasn't aged badly at all. As far as I'm concerned, it still looks quite awesome. It didn't feel weird because of the effects, not even for a second - and the flick is more than 20 years old.
Now, puppets in New Hope, on the other hand, struck me as very awkward and off-putting, and it didn't get much better with Yoda in episodes V and VI.
Not saying every CGI-heavy movie ages as good as T2, or that heavy use of puppets is always and necesarilly bad. But what I am sure of, is that I would't want a puppet based Terminator instead of T1000. In the end - everything has its place.
The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
In this day of mili-second communication by the time the next SW shows we'll know everything about the frick'n movie! Gone are the days of the TOTAL surprise when all eyes are on this one. Just watch.. someone is gonna leak a workprint of this as we get closer there is just too much hype/attention surrounding this behemoth!
MSI GT72S 6QF Dominator Pro S 29th Anniversary Intel i7 6820HK @ 4.0Ghz, 32GB DDR4-2133 RAM, 2x256GB Raid0 Toshiba NVMe 2.5 inch PCIe SSD, Nvidia Geforce GTX 980 OC'ed 200+ Core / 200+ Mem, 17.3 inch LG IPS HD Display @ 75Hz, Intel 7265AC Wifi, Windows 10 Pro BIOS version: .112 EC Firmware version: .105
I think it could've been worse. It's a lot better than the clone trooper helmets for sure.
The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum