I'm enjoying the tone of this season (thus far) more than I thought I would. I blame - but maybe I should say thank - the fact that I had very low expectations, and even with some wonky bits and signature GoTesque resolutions, all is proceeding in a way that I find entertaining and not insulting. There's plenty of room for potential future failures though, fingers crossed!
I'm enjoying the tone of this season (thus far) more than I thought I would. I blame - but maybe I should say thank - the fact that I had very low expectations, and even with some wonky bits and signature GoTesque resolutions, all is proceeding in a way that I find entertaining and not insulting. There's plenty of room for potential future failures though, fingers crossed!
I feel pretty much the same way.
Gonna research those leaks, though :>
On ne peut rien gagner sans perdre; même le paradis exige la mort.
i think they might be holding it for ransom, only thing that makes sence or it would have been spread like wildfire already. but thats a ton of data to move without leaving a trace. whoever gets caught with it can kiss his financial well being goodby lol
The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
I guess the idea was that their standing army wasn't anything special and couldn't compete alone against the Lannister army since they didn't have the time to fully mobilize?
That's the problem with this season playing so loose with time frames... They made it seem like the entire army sneak attacked the Tyrells... It made defeating the Tyrells feel cheap and inconsequential I thought.
The whole point of having a castle is that you can defend it against a much larger force. Even if Lannisters had an advantage in numbers, the battle shouldn't have been fast or easy for them. It just doesn't work that way, not unless the fortress has some glaring defense flaws.
Also, Eugon's teleporting fleet strikes again. Grey Worm only managed to reach Casterly Rock by sea, yet Eugon somehow had time to hit Yara's ships, sail back to King's Landing and then to Casterly Rock to destroy Khaleesi's ships.
Writing like this really makes me happy we only have like 13 or so episodes left.
And meanwhile, Arya is still underway to Winterfell while John Snow teleported from Winterfell to Dragonstone, on the other side of the continent.
The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
The issue is that there is no sense of time.. No weight, and that's purely the fault of the (poor) writing and not that time is relative to the characters.
I've noticed no other season behave in this manner in regards to time (at least not to this extent) it feels as though they're rushing the show now.
The books indicate very clearly through dialogs or character observations how much time has passed.
The show doesn't care. Even Jorah's skin healed practically completely overnight (remember he could only stay for one night longer).
The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
Ellaria Sand is not dead. She might continue to survive for months or even years … unfortunately for her. Yet we won’t see Ellaria on Game of Thrones again, confirms actress Indira Varma
Looks there wont be any continuation for Ellaria Sand.
As people have mentioned Eurons teleportation ships are really fucking retarded.
He manages to attack Ironborn ships to capture the Dorne chicks, sail to Kings Landing and then make it all the way to the other side of the goddamn continent to kill Unsullied ships. WTF. Also the fight at the end of ep 2. How the hell do you know which ships are the enemy in the fucking dark where all the fucking ships look the same!?
Next is where the hell did the Lannisters get such a powerful army? Its mentioned several times how their army was decimated by Robb, the whole Sparrow storyline is because they don't have troops to police King's landing effectively and yet somehow they are fielding and army that defeats the richest House in one fucking day, which brings me to my next thing and the thing that really pisses me off
They fucking take Highgarden, one of the biggest castles in Westeros, in a fucking day. Like seriously? The richest house failed to notice a massive red army moving to their stronghold? They don't have any kind of forward observation posts where they saw that? Seriously? Not to mention the fact they have all the food and cash, they could have just shut the gates and made this a long ass siege. Nope. What we get is the Ollena saying "we were never good with this" SERIOUSLY?
Next is the Iron Bank of Bravos, you know the FREE city, that was created by freed slaves, now they suddenly care about they slave trade? Yeah no.
The timescale makes me think that Dany has been on Westeros for a year without doing fucking anything.
As people have mentioned Eurons teleportation ships are really fucking retarded.
He manages to attack Ironborn ships to capture the Dorne chicks, sail to Kings Landing and then make it all the way to the other side of the goddamn continent to kill Unsullied ships. WTF. Also the fight at the end of ep 2. How the hell do you know which ships are the enemy in the fucking dark where all the fucking ships look the same!?
Next is where the hell did the Lannisters get such a powerful army? Its mentioned several times how their army was decimated by Robb, the whole Sparrow storyline is because they don't have troops to police King's landing effectively and yet somehow they are fielding and army that defeats the richest House in one fucking day, which brings me to my next thing and the thing that really pisses me off
They fucking take Highgarden, one of the biggest castles in Westeros, in a fucking day. Like seriously? The richest house failed to notice a massive red army moving to their stronghold? They don't have any kind of forward observation posts where they saw that? Seriously? Not to mention the fact they have all the food and cash, they could have just shut the gates and made this a long ass siege. Nope. What we get is the Ollena saying "we were never good with this" SERIOUSLY?
Next is the Iron Bank of Bravos, you know the FREE city, that was created by freed slaves, now they suddenly care about they slave trade? Yeah no.
The timescale makes me think that Dany has been on Westeros for a year without doing fucking anything.
But... but... it's HBO!
But seriously this series started it's downhill journey a couple of seasons before - but now, as I wrote few posts earlier, without a solid backing material it became another generic fantasy show. The time line was almost always fucked up, like time flows differently in different parts of Westeros. Cersei hair doesn't change and characters get from place to place in a blink of an eye. Yet white walkers wait for their plot mark to happen.
sar·casm | \ ˈsär-ˌka-zəm \
1: a sharp and often satirical or ironic utterance designed to cut or give pain
2a: a mode of satirical wit depending for its effect on bitter, caustic, and often ironic language that is usually directed against an individual
b: the use or language of sarcasm
It's stupid how she doesn't use the dragons for anything, like King's Landing tourch the port maybe, Euron's fleet or the attack at Castley Rock where she would have gotten a chance at two of them
As people have mentioned Eurons teleportation ships are really fucking retarded.
He manages to attack Ironborn ships to capture the Dorne chicks, sail to Kings Landing and then make it all the way to the other side of the goddamn continent to kill Unsullied ships. WTF. Also the fight at the end of ep 2. How the hell do you know which ships are the enemy in the fucking dark where all the fucking ships look the same!?
Next is where the hell did the Lannisters get such a powerful army? Its mentioned several times how their army was decimated by Robb, the whole Sparrow storyline is because they don't have troops to police King's landing effectively and yet somehow they are fielding and army that defeats the richest House in one fucking day, which brings me to my next thing and the thing that really pisses me off
They fucking take Highgarden, one of the biggest castles in Westeros, in a fucking day. Like seriously? The richest house failed to notice a massive red army moving to their stronghold? They don't have any kind of forward observation posts where they saw that? Seriously? Not to mention the fact they have all the food and cash, they could have just shut the gates and made this a long ass siege. Nope. What we get is the Ollena saying "we were never good with this" SERIOUSLY?
Next is the Iron Bank of Bravos, you know the FREE city, that was created by freed slaves, now they suddenly care about they slave trade? Yeah no.
The timescale makes me think that Dany has been on Westeros for a year without doing fucking anything.
But... but... it's HBO!
But seriously this series started it's downhill journey a couple of seasons before - but now, as I wrote few posts earlier, without a solid backing material it became another generic fantasy show. The time line was almost always fucked up, like time flows differently in different parts of Westeros. Cersei hair doesn't change and characters get from place to place in a blink of an eye. Yet white walkers wait for their plot mark to happen.
The pacing has really become a problem. It almost looks like as if they didn't know how many seasons there will be, they were cut short and now they need to scramble to make the conditions for the endgame happen as fast as possible. I'm starting to hate it, because they built so many characters up, for them now having nothing to do at all. I know the show isn't the books but couldn't someone forsee this?
I always enjoyed the Varys/Littlefinger thing, probably one of my favorite dynamics in the whole story, what do we have now? Two master manipulators are reduced to baffons, one sulks in the shadows the whole time, coming out to tell people useless shit in a profound voice, the other apparently giving up after his mission to bring a Targaryen back has finished, so he's retired or what? Gave up spying?
Spoiler:
Seriously, the spider, Master of Whisperers, a master manipulator with a vast network of informants over two continents, didn't hear anything about a fucking giant Greyjoy fleet (that btw came out of thin air) allying with Cersei? Or how about a massive Lannister army (that btw came out of thin air) marching all over Westeros? Fuck me they are a giant red blob, you think someone would notice.
Have to stop, because the more i think of it the more pissed of i'm becoming. I actually enjoyed Ep 3, but the next day i fucking hated it.
It's still entertaining and well made, but the shows promise of being a gritty serious and "real" story (real as in sometimes heroes die, realistic consequences to actions taken, plans aren't flawless and good and evil are rarely clear cut) have sadly long ago fallen to the wayside. A tragic missed opportunity for something amazingly unique, generic, both true.. but.. still an entertaining show.
I think the people behind it just want it to be over so they can work on their other got follow up shows. The passion and thought just aren't there any more
as i said above ... we need a box with time and gps location with a map in each scene
but yeah they kinda rushing it in S1 they didnt have problems showing armies march ... now they just show the big things without much of a caring about flow of time in each scene -as [b]currently in some story lines between scenes weeks can pass while in others only couple days
... but on the other hand the one thing i hated about the books is how much time is spent on marching without anything happening
It's still entertaining and well made, but the shows promise of being a gritty serious and "real" story (real as in sometimes heroes die, realistic consequences to actions taken, plans aren't flawless and good and evil are rarely clear cut) have sadly long ago fallen to the wayside. A tragic missed opportunity for something amazingly unique, generic, both true.. but.. still an entertaining show.
I think the people behind it just want it to be over so they can work on their other got follow up shows. The passion and thought just aren't there any more
I think it really shows that there are no more books to base it on. Its obvious he has 2 more massive books to tie up loose ends and such, here it really shows how characters who will have more time to develop in the books are being ditched in almost a panic. We've waited 6 seasons for Dany to come to Westeros and suddenly all her allies are gone in 10 minutes.
I completely agree its entertaining, but after thinking about EP 3 which i really liked at the end, the sloppy pacing, timeline management and just plot holes are starting to get to me.
No, seriously, out of all proper complaints this one is just..
It could be actually pretty symbolic.. This is a new, "reborn" Cersei who has finally become THE Queen, more badass and ruthless (burning her son etc) and not giving a fuck (sleeping openly with her brother now) than the woman she was before the whole Sparrow clusterfuck
You can check the character paths here. It took Dany 6 seasons to get through Essos and then she just teleported into Westeros.
And you can see that it is at least 2000 miles from King's Landing through Castely Rock to Highgarden. On foot without taking breaks and sleeping it would take them 28 days. Now you have to sleep, shit eat, you are walking in armor, there is no mass transport. So this battle would take 3 months to happen, at least.
In the mean time Jon made at least 3000 miles to see the white pussy. And Arya made only around 50 miles. Get a grip bitch you been slow as fuck.
thing is we have no idea about time between storylines and if they take place at the same time .. the fact that scenes appear in same episode dosnt mean they take place at the same time in relation to storylines of other people and because of that it might look like teleporting (because they are skipping the traveling fluff i hate in the books) as there is no indication of time
... Sam's timeline it looks like he was doing lowly task and then suddenly healed jorah in one day ... but thing is the pooopsoup montage could be summary of months of his life => so looking at it in way of miles per eisode will look as teleporting for sure, when there might be scenes withing same episodes that are weeks apart from each other ( Euron traveling to the Rock by boats in same timeframe Jaime travels to Highgarden on foot .... in this ep)
In the second episode, Jamie tried to convince Randyll Tarly (bannerman to the Tyrells) so that he will betray the Tyrells and surely he did judging by the ep 4 trailer. Therefore (obviously offscreen) that's what happened. Also the Lannister army got bigger because of that (there was one more big name that made their army bigger but i can't remember what was it, not Freys who are almost extinct i guess).
As for the time travelling and gaping plot holes - yep, the books are over. The battles are a big yawn since the battle of the bastards, hardhome or blackwater bay.
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum