Marvel's The Punisher (Netflix TV Series)
Page 5 of 10 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10  Next
tonizito
VIP Member



Posts: 52341
Location: Portugal, the shithole of Europe.
PostPosted: Sat, 18th Nov 2017 20:26    Post subject:
I'm three episodes in and so far it's much better than derpfenders, iron fist, like cage and jj at least.


boundle (thoughts on cracking AITD) wrote:
i guess thouth if without a legit key the installation was rolling back we are all fucking then
Back to top
h0rnyfavn
Serial Humper



Posts: 13923

PostPosted: Sat, 18th Nov 2017 22:29    Post subject:
I'm also three episodes in.. The first one was OK, the second and the third one felt stretched out too much, filled with boring, unnecessary dialogues and scenes...

Sauronich

Quote:
the Micro's family and Dinah subplots are trash.


+1

=> boring.

Quote:
very few scens of Frank actually fucking shit up, and the ones that are there aren't even shot very well.


So far... +1

Quote:
they spend way too much time in that basement.


+1

I'm already fed up with this basement..

I really hope it gets better...The episode 3 ending was promising..


1) Lenovo Legion 7 (AMD Ryzen 7 5800H, RTX 3080 16Gb, 32Gb DDR4, SSD 1TB +2TB

2) SFFPC (streaming via Moonlight+ Sunshine)
Back to top
wawrzul




Posts: 2336
Location: Cracow, Poland
PostPosted: Sun, 19th Nov 2017 12:55    Post subject:
Watched the whole season.
It's hard to rate it. It was advertised as more of an action show than drama (vide the "One" trailer). And then up to the 9th episode it's mostly drama with some parts being really irritating but overall tolerable. And from the 10th episode it gets mighty bloody in a good way. The ending and the introduction of
 Spoiler:
 

Also some of the action scenes were great, Frank is a hell of a bullet sponge. Others - not so much.
And i hated to see another show with some SJW bullshit (gun control laws, terrorism) jacked in - even storywise it had no place IMO.
I would much rather see Frank kill tons of mobsters than more flashbacks of his family. Only symbolic
 Spoiler:
 
was meaningful.
Overall i think it's a 6/10, although it's a fanboy rating. Bernthal makes a good Punisher and the guy who played Micro and Russo (this guy was good in Westworld too) were good as well. I would like the show to have more seasons but IMO they should refocus the show.

EDIT: I forgot one of the most important faults - the
 Spoiler:
 
part of the plot which sucked as well in Daredevil's S02. It could be so much better if it was simply a mob hit that killed his family, like in the comics.
Back to top
Yuri




Posts: 11008

PostPosted: Sun, 19th Nov 2017 17:50    Post subject:
Hopefully I can get used to the dopey look they've given Punisher in the show because it cracks me up every time I see him.



1 and 2 are still amazing.
Back to top
tonizito
VIP Member



Posts: 52341
Location: Portugal, the shithole of Europe.
PostPosted: Sun, 19th Nov 2017 18:09    Post subject:
wawrzul wrote:
And i hated to see another show with some SJW bullshit (gun control laws, terrorism) jacked in - even storywise it had no place IMO.
...the fuck?!
How is gun control and terrorism SJW bullshit?

Are You Serious


boundle (thoughts on cracking AITD) wrote:
i guess thouth if without a legit key the installation was rolling back we are all fucking then
Back to top
EyePatchLives




Posts: 5764
Location: Israel.
PostPosted: Sun, 19th Nov 2017 18:35    Post subject:
Goddamn, Frank was ruthless and I loved it. They didn't tone down anything. Very Happy

Face, meet broken mirror. Fuck Yeah


"I think Call of Duty resonates because it's believable and relatable," Sledgehammer Games cofounder Michael Condrey says.

Believable and relatable...Yep, sounds like Call of Duty
Back to top
KillerCrocker




Posts: 20558

PostPosted: Sun, 19th Nov 2017 20:32    Post subject:
I Love 2004 punisher. Thomas Jane is Punisher for me... I did not much liked any other punisher stuff except for thomas jane short.

How is the show compared ?


5080 | ps5 pro

Sin317-"im 31 years old and still surprised at how much shit comes out of my ass actually ..."
SteamDRM-"Call of Duty is the symbol of the true perfection in every aspect. Call of Duty games are like Mozart's/Beethoven's symphonies"
deadpoetic-"are you new to the cyberspace?"
Back to top
Yuri




Posts: 11008

PostPosted: Sun, 19th Nov 2017 20:42    Post subject:
Back to top
Bob Barnsen




Posts: 31972
Location: Germoney
PostPosted: Sun, 19th Nov 2017 20:46    Post subject:
KillerCrocker wrote:
I Love 2004 punisher. Thomas Jane is Punisher for me... I did not much liked any other punisher stuff except for thomas jane short.

How is the show compared ?


+1 to the question.


Enthoo Evolv ATX TG // Asus Prime x370 // Ryzen 1700 // Gainward GTX 1080 // 16GB DDR4-3200
Back to top
Aquma




Posts: 2805

PostPosted: Sun, 19th Nov 2017 23:39    Post subject:
Bob Barnsen wrote:
KillerCrocker wrote:
I Love 2004 punisher. Thomas Jane is Punisher for me... I did not much liked any other punisher stuff except for thomas jane short.

How is the show compared ?


+1 to the question.


I suppose "different" is the answer.

I liked Jane too, but there's something really physical, primal even, about Bernthal's portrayal of Castle. It's less "I'm gonna make you kill your family and then put a bullet in your head" Punisher and more "I'm gonna rip your throat with my teeth while I'm spitting out bullets you shot me with" Punisher. He's not sophisticated in any conceivable way, his face actually looks even sorta dumb at times, but when he starts killing he looks like a force of nature, in a way that Jane never really did.
Back to top
Aquma




Posts: 2805

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 00:09    Post subject:
I finished it. Liked it a lot overall, despite some bigger and smaller holes in the script. I think the pacing and structure were pretty solid. I even enjoyed Micro and his family (except for the kid, that stuff could've been dropped, really), because they emphasized the differences between both men and their priorities. I liked how the unstable vet subplot tied into the larger storyline in the second half of the season. Some episodes were really tense and nicely done.

I'm really surprised at the amount of leeway they got from Marvel when it comes to brutality. Sure, it's not the most violent show on TV, some corners are cut - for example, you won't see live decapitation or stuff like that. During the most brutal scenes camera usually hangs in a place that doesn't allow you to see everything, but... it's enough. The real brutality lies in the way they use the stuff they got. You'll still see Castle using a chopped off head as an improvised grenade, or bash a guy's head in with a rock and then literally spit out parts of his brain into a bucket. Grim, heavy shit... and it works, it really does.

If I had to name one complaint it would be that there's too little Punisher and too much Frank Castle. Because it really isn't the same thing. Making everything personal and tied to his past doesn't serve Punisher well. An ex-solider who wants revenge for his family isn't really Punisher - he becomes Punisher when he starts killing scumbags because they're scumbags, because he sees his family's killer's face in the face of every single one of them. That's a critical difference the show doesn't really recognize - in fact, I think Daredevil season 2 captured Punisher better in this regard.
Back to top
WaldoJ
VIP Member



Posts: 32678

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 01:28    Post subject:
Bob Barnsen wrote:
KillerCrocker wrote:
I Love 2004 punisher. Thomas Jane is Punisher for me... I did not much liked any other punisher stuff except for thomas jane short.

How is the show compared ?


+1 to the question.


Tommy Jane wasn't broken.
He was hardcore. He was a bad ass.
Wasn't afraid and was a smart vigilante.

This one is punisher is broken and in turmoil and dealing with ptsd of losing his family and shit and it's like... the punisher we saw in daredevil was more of a militarized tommy Jane. Bad ass, violent, accepted his shit and still lives with it but it's not a struggle.

Here it's a struggle. It's not a bad show but it's not the punisher we saw in daredevil. It's more like what the punisher would become. This is a step back in character progression. He's always mopey always ptsd and that wasn't the vibe in daredevil.

Had they kept the daredevil punisher it would be a tommy Jane had he been a soldier punisher and not an ex cop. Would have been much more awesome.

They added depth that wasn't needed and added wounds that for some reason came back a year after he dealt with daredevil.


Sin317 wrote:
I win, you lose. Or Go fuck yourself.
Back to top
Aquma




Posts: 2805

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 09:48    Post subject:
Yeah, I also think they needlessly went back to square one in a sense. End of his arc in Daredevil suggested a different starting point than we actually got in Punisher season 1. I'd rather see him move forward too.

I think part of the reason is that they really wanted to make a military drama/thriller, in an effort to give the show a different identity, like they did with LC and JJ - both of these were squarely grounded in the setting, however, because they had superpowered protagonists (and sometimes antagonists). Here it backfired slightly, IMO, because it just doesn't feel like a Marvel/Punisher show, and Castle doesn't exactly feel like the guy he should be.
Back to top
h0rnyfavn
Serial Humper



Posts: 13923

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 11:36    Post subject:
I've just finished it.

7.5/10
.
...mostly for the last 4 episodes. I'm glad I managed to suffer through the boring midseason. Laughing

@WaldoJ
Quote:
a step back in character progression. He's always mopey always ptsd and that wasn't the vibe in daredevil.


Quote:
added wounds that for some reason came back a year after he dealt with daredevil.


Indeed. I could understand if it was a prequel to daredevil events but it's not, so it's really strange.


1) Lenovo Legion 7 (AMD Ryzen 7 5800H, RTX 3080 16Gb, 32Gb DDR4, SSD 1TB +2TB

2) SFFPC (streaming via Moonlight+ Sunshine)
Back to top
garus
VIP Member



Posts: 34196

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 11:39    Post subject:
snip


Last edited by garus on Tue, 27th Aug 2024 21:32; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
difm




Posts: 6618

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 12:42    Post subject:
I think the point they're trying to make is that he will be forever haunted by the tragedy and perhaps they're building the character again for its own this time?


i5 6600k @ 4.3 GHz | MSI z170 Gaming M7 | 32GB Kingston HyperX Fury | 850 Evo 500GB | EVGA 1070 SC | Seasonic X-660 | CM Storm Stryker
Back to top
Mister_s




Posts: 19862

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 15:44    Post subject:
After three eps I do like it (also the drama), but this is not what I expected. It's more "ex-Punisher".
Back to top
Bob Barnsen




Posts: 31972
Location: Germoney
PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 18:12    Post subject:
Thanks for the impressions guys.

Might take a look at some episodes too. Though it doesn't sound like a show that is focussed about action scenes and revenge - like the movies.


Enthoo Evolv ATX TG // Asus Prime x370 // Ryzen 1700 // Gainward GTX 1080 // 16GB DDR4-3200
Back to top
4treyu




Posts: 23498

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 20:19    Post subject:
Mister_s wrote:
After three eps I do like it (also the drama), but this is not what I expected. It's more "ex-Punisher".


+1

This is less comics-like and more oriented to drama/conspiracy, which isn't a bad thing, unless you were exclusively looking for the comics approach. For that, you have the bazillion super-hero crapola shows currently infesting the tv schedules, which I don't even bother with watching. This one, unless it screws up big before I'm done with the season, has a very good chance of entering my yearly lineup.
Back to top
h0rnyfavn
Serial Humper



Posts: 13923

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 20:58    Post subject:
@4treyu
Quote:
which isn't a bad thing,


It's a not a bad thing.. the writing and pacing should be really good though..which is not the case.

I'd say it's a solid 7.5 but it could have been much better writing-wise (drama & story) or\and action-wise (except for the last 3-4 episodes that are already pretty good in this regard)


1) Lenovo Legion 7 (AMD Ryzen 7 5800H, RTX 3080 16Gb, 32Gb DDR4, SSD 1TB +2TB

2) SFFPC (streaming via Moonlight+ Sunshine)
Back to top
Aquma




Posts: 2805

PostPosted: Mon, 20th Nov 2017 23:46    Post subject:
I don't think it has anything to do with comic-book orientation, tbh. Punisher is a weird one and it's entirely possible to make a show about him without it feeling like a comic-book, but at the same time, without making his character something different, the way this show did. In fact, there's a whole comic-book series about Castle that does just that - tells Punisher stories without them feeling like anything remotely tied to Marvel. This incarnation of the character actually takes many ideas from these stories (like making him a PTSD-suffering vet, and a somewhat unstable person overall), but it adds less badassery and focus to the mix.
Back to top
Lathieza




Posts: 7146
Location: NL
PostPosted: Tue, 21st Nov 2017 00:16    Post subject:
7.5 for me as well!!


Empty again Sad
Back to top
wawrzul




Posts: 2336
Location: Cracow, Poland
PostPosted: Tue, 21st Nov 2017 09:05    Post subject:
tonizito wrote:
wawrzul wrote:
And i hated to see another show with some SJW bullshit (gun control laws, terrorism) jacked in - even storywise it had no place IMO.
...the fuck?!
How is gun control and terrorism SJW bullshit?

Are You Serious

1. Putting a white psycho male blowing shit up and killing people in times where it's pretty normal order of business for muslims to do so. Just to please some butthurt lefties. At least there was no "white people should die" narrative from the Wolfenstein. Movies and TV shows usually are anchored in the climate of the times when they were filmed. Therefore i call bullshit.
2. Gun control is bullshit, plain and simple. Can't believe even Bernthal is a strong believer. It would be funny to see a pedestrian pull out a gun and shoot a wanted "terrorist" (Castle) during one of the chases. Too bad it's NY and not TX.
3. It was actually nice to Karen's character to point out the hypocrisy of gun control to the dumbass senator. So +1 for that.

A few years back i wouldn't say shit about the above but lately it's everywhere. Tv shows and movies, lately even games Sad It's becoming harder to ignore and focus on the fun.
Back to top
tonizito
VIP Member



Posts: 52341
Location: Portugal, the shithole of Europe.
PostPosted: Tue, 21st Nov 2017 09:36    Post subject:
I don't even...

1. Have you been seeing the news lately in the US? With all the white people shooting and killing several folks (well at least most of them are white too, so not much ground for actual SJW's to start building a race war / white supremacist narrative Laughing) per event? Even before that nut in vegas there were a LOT in the US.
2. I don't agree but it isn't SJW bullshit, what the hell?
3. Not there yet.

Seems to me that you're taking the "I don't agree with that, that's nazi stuff" from the actual left leaning idiots and turning it around to "I don't agree with that, that's SJW stuff", broadening the spectrum of what really is "SJW bullshit"... for what?
Good luck with that shit...


boundle (thoughts on cracking AITD) wrote:
i guess thouth if without a legit key the installation was rolling back we are all fucking then
Back to top
wawrzul




Posts: 2336
Location: Cracow, Poland
PostPosted: Tue, 21st Nov 2017 10:26    Post subject:
tonizito wrote:
I don't even...

1. Have you been seeing the news lately in the US? With all the white people shooting and killing several folks (well at least most of them are white too, so not much ground for actual SJW's to start building a race war / white supremacist narrative Laughing) per event? Even before that nut in vegas there were a LOT in the US.
2. I don't agree but it isn't SJW bullshit, what the hell?
3. Not there yet.

Seems to me that you're taking the "I don't agree with that, that's nazi stuff" from the actual left leaning idiots and turning it around to "I don't agree with that, that's SJW stuff", broadening the spectrum of what really is "SJW bullshit"... for what?
Good luck with that shit...


1. Of course, i know what's going on. Do we really have to do numbers here? Plus, The Punisher was already filmed before Las Vegas. As for other shootings and bombing - you are right of course. Like i said - it's usually the current climate influencing the plot. Unabomber and Columbine are far gone, Boston Marathon less so.
2. It is SJW bullshit because each time there is a story about a nut killing people with a gun the gun control maniacs appear. It is SJW bullshit mainly because of ignoring key factors like guns being tools or gun control working only with lawful people.
3. If i spoiled it i'm sorry. I thought you watched the whole show by now.

As for the last part - you could be right. In the times we live in a lot of stuff is put upside down. I'm still waiting for a Commando remake with Jodie Foster. What i associate with "SJW bullshit" is basically putting things like tradition, human nature and logic upside down just because it is not compatible with leftie thinking. Like playing a video game and having the main white male superhero yell "fuck you, u white ass nazi fucks" and a black chick being racist because of nazis being racist. Just in case i missed the white ass nazi fucks being white. And nazi.

As for the TV show - it's too bad they focused so much on Frank's PTSD and not tried something different. I liked how in Punisher Warzone Frank killed an undercover cop and felt guilty. They could do such a thing here too.

EDIT: typos.
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8281
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Tue, 21st Nov 2017 12:58    Post subject:
wawrzul wrote:

2. It is SJW bullshit because each time there is a story about a nut killing people with a gun the gun control maniacs appear. It is SJW bullshit mainly because of ignoring key factors like guns being tools or gun control working only with lawful people.

This should be taken to the news/Trump section, but this is too much bullshit to ignore. You're forgetting one minor aspect: the numbers in rest of the world.
There's only one country with so many mass killings using firearms. And there's only one country with such lenient laws when it comes to firearms. And guess what? They're the same country.


The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
Back to top
wawrzul




Posts: 2336
Location: Cracow, Poland
PostPosted: Tue, 21st Nov 2017 14:10    Post subject:
Il_Padrino wrote:
wawrzul wrote:

2. It is SJW bullshit because each time there is a story about a nut killing people with a gun the gun control maniacs appear. It is SJW bullshit mainly because of ignoring key factors like guns being tools or gun control working only with lawful people.

This should be taken to the news/Trump section, but this is too much bullshit to ignore. You're forgetting one minor aspect: the numbers in rest of the world.
There's only one country with so many mass killings using firearms. And there's only one country with such lenient laws when it comes to firearms. And guess what? They're the same country.

So firearms kill people? Not people kill people? Is it strictly firearm per person statistic? I didn't hear about any mass shootings in Serbia (it's in second place in guns per 100 residents estimate, although it is about 45% less than US). Not to mention the fact that not that many mass shootings are done by veterans suffering from PTSD (in regards to the tv show).
I'd say the Americans are the problem, not firearms. They pull the trigger.

EDIT: I don't mean to diminish the tragedy that are mass shootings. I just think people should be blamed in the first place. Gun is a tool for a person doing the deed. Regulations simply don't work because a criminal/psycho/crazed veteran doesn't give a shit if society doesn't allow him owning a firearm.
Back to top
Aquma




Posts: 2805

PostPosted: Tue, 21st Nov 2017 15:57    Post subject:
Gun is a tool, but it's also one that makes killing easier - by design. And I don't just mean effectiveness, although it is a factor, since no one in their right mind will say you can kill many people with a knife as easily, as with a firearm. But I think that, in the end, it all comes down to the fact that, if you want to kill someone using a knife, you have to come closer and actually do the deed, sometimes looking someone in the face, because you won't always be able to do it in one blow. Your victim might struggle, might even overpower you, given enough adrenaline (different story with someone properly trained, but still). With a gun, you just extend your hand and squeeze the trigger, which - to me, at least - seems a lot more impersonal, a lot easier to do. And there's also less danger for the murderer.

So, for every unstable, untrained individual, a simple, average Joe, gun is a much more dangerous, and more effective, tool to wreak havoc. Of course, it's also a better means of defense. Someone who owns a gun can stop someone dangerous, a woman can use it to defend herself against someone physically more powerful. But that argument can also be turned on its head. Since getting guns in USA is a lot easier than in other countries, it's easier for criminals too, since there's just so many weapons on the market. Sure, people from real, organized crime, would probably have managed to get a gun even in a more restrictive environment, but the same isn't necessarily true for small time crooks or psychos. It's not about giving a shit, it's about availability and ease.

Personally I don't think guns should be banned, but I do think their sales need to be regulated somehow. You need to make sure you know who has them, possibly also for what reason. You need to ascertain they won't be able to legally resell them, or at least you need to know the identity of the new owner - and you need to be able to stop the transaction, if he doesn't pass a background check. Not doing that is just asking for trouble. There are countries with liberal gun laws, like Finland and Sweden, where there aren't nearly as many mass shootings (or even just shootings), as in USA. But, the thing is, despite a large number of firearms owned by the people, and generally lenient laws, you still have to get a license to own a gun in both of these countries - it's never as easy as just going to the store. In the US even that is seen as needless and an attack on the second amendment. Sure, you need to get through a background check when you buy a gun from a store, but there are several loopholes (private sales, gun shows), that essentially make this requirement a dead law.
Back to top
garus
VIP Member



Posts: 34196

PostPosted: Tue, 21st Nov 2017 17:40    Post subject:
snip


Last edited by garus on Tue, 27th Aug 2024 21:32; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
h0rnyfavn
Serial Humper



Posts: 13923

PostPosted: Tue, 21st Nov 2017 17:53    Post subject:
God created men and Sam Colt made them equal. Nuff said. Very Happy

Criminals have access to guns anyways regardless of laws and the police is not always there when they are needed or they just might be too late..

Back in the days only slaves and the likes of were not allowed to have weapons.. You wanna be a slave or a man able to protect yourself and your loved ones when faced with an armed assailant?

I'm not against background checks and some testing before a person can be allowed to buy a gun obviously.


1) Lenovo Legion 7 (AMD Ryzen 7 5800H, RTX 3080 16Gb, 32Gb DDR4, SSD 1TB +2TB

2) SFFPC (streaming via Moonlight+ Sunshine)
Back to top
Page 5 of 10 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Movie & TV Sparks Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group