The Witcher 3's world instantly became more interesting after I disabled the mini-map and POIs, upped the difficulty to the hardest one and installed the Friendly HUD with only a toggleable mini-compass and nothing else on the screen. Full_immersion_mode and free from the visual clutter triggering silly OCDs, the way such well-crafted worlds deserve to be played
Hope there will be an equivalent combo available for Cyberpunk as well to quench my nonaugmented explorative body.
You would do a quest with a level 3 drowner and 5 minutes later you stumble upon a 38 lvl one you can't finish until the end of the game.
How many times did that happen? Not often. Would it make more sense if the quest you mentioned was for your level at that stage? It was just a high level combat encounter at an early stage.
@ixigia: it's not only the visual clutter, you can disable that. I just don't understand why developers feel the need to fill the awesome world they created with useless loot. Maybe there are enough gamers that like that stuff, I don't know.
W3 was full with useless ? too. Skellige was one big treasure hunt for scrap items. On top of that a lot of the side quests were locked behind stupid level caps. You would do a quest with a level 3 drowner and 5 minutes later you stumble upon a 38 lvl one you can't finish until the end of the game. For an open world game you were railroaded to play a certain way from the start. If the map was 50% smaller there wouldn't have been a difference since most of it was very barren too.
Yeah but beside Skellige the other areas were okay.
I think the way they did open world in Witcher 3 and all it's "?" is the best way. It's logical, not too big and not tedious.
Compared to say Ubisoft games, like AC Odyssey or Origins. So many fucking "?" most are boring and meaningless and then there is 8 million collectibles.
It was tedious. At some point i stopped exploring and just went from quest to quest until it was done.
I just don't understand why developers feel the need to fill the awesome world they created with useless loot.
Because if you don't, people complain that there is nothing to do, that your world is empty. Vavra (Kingdom Come/Mafia creator) has talked a bit about this before, the "potato" design, where the player comes across some new thing every 10 meters. You can probably lay a lot of the blame for the modern industry's obsession with it at the feet of Ubisoft, since that is basically the defining trait of their games.
I just don't understand why developers feel the need to fill the awesome world they created with useless loot.
Because if you don't, people complain that there is nothing to do, that your world is empty. Vavra (Kingdom Come/Mafia creator) has talked a bit about this before, the "potato" design, where the player comes across some new thing every 10 meters. You can probably lay a lot of the blame for the modern industry's obsession with it at the feet of Ubisoft, since that is basically the defining trait of their games.
This isnt a flaw or something modern. Valve used this principle all the way back in 1997 when they were revamping Half Life.
Quote:
The second step in the pre-cabal process was to analyze what was fun about our prototype level. The first theory we came up with was the theory of "experiential density" — the amount of "things" that happen to and are done by the player per unit of time and area of a map. Our goal was that, once active, the player never had to wait too long before the next stimulus, be it monster, special effect, plot point, action sequence, and so on. Since we couldn’t really bring all these experiences to the player (a relentless series of them would just get tedious), all content is distance based, not time based, and no activities are started outside the player’s control. If the players are in the mood for more action, all they need to do is move forward and within a few seconds something will happen.
Dense gameworlds that have sustained rhythm to the action are the best. And they're very rare. Vavra's game is a pretty mediocre one all in all, i wouldnt look at him for design advice. He made a shitty cumbersome fighting system and a boring world to traverse because his priorities were out of order. Realism over gameplay.
The maps in Witcher 3 are nice to look at, but id never call the open world the best in any game. Its on the lower end of the spectrum. Its how you utilise the space, not how pretty it looks. Call of Prypiat and Gothic are still the benchmark games for this.
One of the biggest issue is to fill a huge well-defined and inspired world with quality content. Take any reasonably large Open World game, remove ALL the pointless (although some people like this kind of stuff) "collect these 400 items", "perform this challenge and it's variations 400 times", "gain extra credits by performing these 400 stunts" etc. and fill up all those hours of low quality crap with proper quality content/involved written quests/missions and the game would take much much longer to finish at which point the investment vs returns is in the red no matter how awesome the game ultimately is.
There's no working formula to prolong a game with pure quality content compared to filling it with all sorts of easy additions that can be found in games like Far Cry 2-Pink Dawn, GTA SA->V, AssCreed-series and so on.
Mafia 2 tried to avoid going down that route and what we have is a game that has a fairly short campaign and not much else to do. The increase in man hours to create Empire Bay in all it's visual glory (at the time, and to be honest it's still quite pretty, esp. during opening act) compared to creating Lost Heaven which, while great for it's time, took a fraction of time since it didn't use the high quality high resolution textures and advanced effects the later games used, and thus we had a campaign that lasted longer with very little in the way of filler.
With Mafia 3 they chose to go the GTA route while screwing up the writing, setting and characters but that's a different matter.
Successful Open World RPG's seems to have a somewhat easier task compared to action games in that regard. The extra filler isn't as tedious or as pointless as in OW action games due to RPG's being much more story based and with an audience that is role playing and have a different mindset when it comes to quests outside the main quest.
Burned out in W3, too, with all the Side quests triggering my OCD, lol.
That's happening in all "Open world" games to me, I try to do all the side stuff and eventually I have to force myself to finish the main quest and be done with it.
Well, properly done Open World is my fave format when it comes to a game that is written with that in mind and made well. The immersion (loading screens tend to snap you out of the "world") as well as freedom to go wherever you want (freedom of choice) is pretty damn sexy.
Not that open world in itself is #1, it entirely depends on the style, direction and goal of the game is.
You would do a quest with a level 3 drowner and 5 minutes later you stumble upon a 38 lvl one you can't finish until the end of the game.
How many times did that happen? Not often. Would it make more sense if the quest you mentioned was for your level at that stage? It was just a high level combat encounter at an early stage.
In Velen it happens 7 times. I have no problem with encountering high level monsters, but the way it was implemented it was meant for you to track back just to kill a stronger monster for the same generic loot. In one area with three monster nests you had a 6 lvl one, which was meant to be killed for when you first visit the area through the main quest, then an 18 lvl one and a 36 lvl one. All of them were generic ?. It didn't reward the player whatsover, if the player decided to clear a higher level encounter early on. Also, you had to go back midway to clear the 18 lvl one to get the xp, otherwise the game thinks you're too overpowered and you don't get shit. It was all meant to be filler and extended the play time. I thought the level caps was the biggest issue the game had. And I'm not even talking about the different narrative sidequests you can miss the xp on, because there are 3 lvl quests on the other side of the map and once you get there you're well over the 5 level limit.
For me personally Witcher 3 is the best implementation of an open world yet, even though I thought RDR2 was awesome. So I hope they do what they did with every new game they made, make it even more awesome. What excites me most about this, since I am sure they'll nail things like story and game, is the vertical design. I am bored of flat worlds with empty spaces. Bring on the scifi city!
Isn't the whole "vertical" thing basically just a bunch of corridor shooter levels? I'm not sure why open world types would be excited by it. I seriously doubt they will have more than a few floors and rooms per building being explorable outside specific story missions and the like.
Dunno if it was allrdy posted but here is an interview with Mike Pondsmith, creator of Cyberpunk 2020:
Mike is such a great guy, love his enthusiasm for the game he even has something to say about the fuckwits who are trying to stir up shit on Ree and other places like it:
It's nice to see how he is so actively involved in the project, Mike's always a pleasure to listen to. With that badass voice he definitely could (*should*) show up as an NPC or as some sort of virtual gamemaster.
It's nice to see how he is so actively involved in the project, Mike's always a pleasure to listen to. With that badass voice he definitely could (*should*) show up as an NPC or as some sort of virtual gamemaster.
Mike mentionted in an interview what he was surprised there was a following for Cyberpunk who wanted the tabletop to be available in Poland. I don't think he was talking about CDPR (when they were young entrepreneurs) but it may be the case really. I like that he knows exactly how showbusiness works and licenses get damaged, destroyed or are bought and forgotten by corporations. He said it in 2019 and 2018 that he is glad CDPR got the job and that he really likes what they did (thus far). He apparently is deeply involved in how the world looks and feels.
Pondsmith mentioned the first time he saw a snippet of the game (before 2018 demo) and saw the guns. They were shiny metallic (as in pretty, i guess) and he said that ain't gonna work. They have to be over-the-top and punk. So i guess he at least will be correcting anything that's not fitting for the world in the game.
Also, a french store is giving a CP2077 comic book for preorders. Strange because no one else does. There is even a screenshot of it.
I was surprised he gave input on something like that in the video (the weapons). It shows he's involved and is most likely a (PC/console) gamer himself.
Someone who's not understanding graphics or modern games would just say "yes, it looks very nice, its just as good as in those other computer games i've googled, go with this."
I doubt they could get input like that from someone like Sapkowski
I was surprised he gave input on something like that in the video (the weapons). It shows he's involved and is most likely a (PC/console) gamer himself.
Someone who's not understanding graphics or modern games would just say "yes, it looks very nice, its just as good as in those other computer games i've googled, go with this."
I doubt they could get input like that from someone like Sapkowski
Lol, exactly. I imagined Sapkowski reaction to Roach being a car in W3. "I want cash for this"
On other note - i hope Pondsmith voices a character. Such silky smooth black voice, damn.
Depends on what he's doing. He plays the average joe / generic person quite well. E.g Neo, we're supposed to see him (at first) as the average joe working in an office, a carbon copy of millions of other people doing and looking pretty much the same as him. He's not supposed to have tons of charisma and unique features.
He actually has more charisma as a person than as a character, it's usually the other way around, actors are often assholes but you don't think that when you see them as a character.
Don't get me wrong, I love all of his roles/characters and especially him as a person, he may not be a good actor, but he fits the roles he chooses and is a really cool dude.
Yeah, exactly. Kind of like i see Arnie - he is no great actor (he did try a little in Collateral Damaga) but a good fit in movies like The Terminator (only 1 and 2 are worth mentioning) or Predator.
I'm actually scared that Reeves will be too "nice" in CP2077. However hearing that he has an agenda as Johnny and being strongly implied that he isn't really
Spoiler:
dead
(in 2/2 interviews with Mike Pondsmith at E3 is strongly implied by the man himself) calms me down. I hope for some depth here dammit.
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum