The Irishman (2019)
Page 4 of 4 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75740
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 17:26    Post subject:
Hence, "stupid people". "Muh cluffhungurr" Laughing

Is this why Lost was popular despite being absolute garbage after season 2? Because they finished each episode with a cluffhungurr and that dreaded silly Giacchino melodramatic strings score? Laughing


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
garus
VIP Member



Posts: 34196

PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 17:29    Post subject:
snip


Last edited by garus on Tue, 27th Aug 2024 21:24; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
StEFaN7




Posts: 6367
Location: them swamps
PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 17:49    Post subject:
lol wut


I can see your soul at the edges of your eyes..
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75740
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 18:38    Post subject:
garus wrote:
You hating on people who didn't finish The Wire etc is (to me) comparable to neckbeards feeling superior they get references to sci-fi in Rick and Morty.

It's great you enjoy it, I also enjoyed it but let's not pretend The Wire has mass-appeal that is only ruined by hurdurrs.

I only have subjective data, but a lot of it over the years. Among my circle of people, the ones that have tried it and hated it are not the brightest, to say the least. Especially after listening to their reasons why.

I know the politically correct thing to say is "different tastes mkay", but I will not ignore patterns in taste and the the people with it. You may claim that I simply have not met enough people, which I'll grant you, but I will not ignore the patterns I have for political correctness or being friendly. Want to call me elitists? I don't really care, I don't see that as an insult.

garus wrote:
And about Lost, yet again you discovered nothing new. Yes, Lost rode the mystery wave for a long time with some "character drama" to pad out the runtime. I watched it fully just to get a conclusion which I never got. That to me ruined the whole series - but a lot of people enjoyed the ride even when getting slapped in the face in the final episode Very Happy

Those filler character episodes were often far superior to "teh mysturry". Likely because they were given to one-time writers, rather than the main trio. The series lost (badum) a lot of its charm when it moved to the shorter series formats with season 4.


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75740
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 18:42    Post subject:
BTW, I haven't seen The Irishman and probably won't either; this film isn't the point anyway—it's a wider issue.


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
PickupArtist




Posts: 10787

PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 19:10    Post subject:
lost, the wire, this is the irshman topic u degenerates
Back to top
Morphineus
VIP Member



Posts: 24939
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 19:53    Post subject:
Oooooooooooh, me and the wife were part of that 18%

We turned it on for movie night, didn't even bother to check how long it was. 2 hours in it felt like it was coming to an end... the wife wanted to get some more water and then DU DU DUUUUU we saw it was 1,5 hours still left. We laughed about it, got drinks and watched it till the end.

I enjoyed it, but that de-aging 'tech' was quite off-putting most of the time. And funny bad at other times. That geriatric kungfu shopkeeper scene. Laughing They really needed body doubles.


Back to top
StEFaN7




Posts: 6367
Location: them swamps
PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 20:50    Post subject:
LeoNatan wrote:
Among my circle of people, the ones that have tried it and hated it are not the brightest, to say the least. Especially after listening to their reasons why.

yet the same dumb reasons are all over this forum, be it games or movies, and in this case from people who claim to "know" movies btw.

anyway i watched the movie on release day, i thought it was ok, overhyped because it was not excelent but hype was real for cast, director, runtime etc. the standout was pacino, his scenes with graham were some of the best scenes in the movie.

i dont get why this movie needed deaging except if scorsese wanted this exact cast, couse he could have gotten a younger cast to play most of the movie then do some makeup for the ending, but that wouldnt be the same movie without this cast. the deaging didnt really worked, deniro wasnt fat when he was young so it looked strange, he always looked the same unlike something christian bale would do. so sometimes it worked and sometimes not.

i was never bored, but for the amount of runtime it has i thought the story was a bit stretched and the ending kinda rushed.

all in all it was a good movie but not an epic, epic only if you look at it from a different angle.


I can see your soul at the edges of your eyes..
Back to top
WaldoJ
VIP Member



Posts: 32678

PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 21:46    Post subject:
garus wrote:
I mean isn't it obvious why people binge easier than watch a long movie? Waldolol should know since he is the knowitall of the business Laughing Each episode of bingeable shows has a cliffhanger or a hook to keep you watching. In a long movie the payoff is usually delayed to the very end.

Would people binge a boring TV show that gave them no incentive to watch the next episode? I hardly think so.


(I haven't watched Irishman and don't intend to, not my type of movie - I felt 30 years older after finishing good fellas. I would die of old age after adding this on top)


Bingey shows have cliffhanger cause they're essentially a single product packaged into several episodes. They're also following a tv formula to keep people interested and keep ratings up. However... Old shows that follow this formula of cliffhangers... Don't do well when binging. Alias is a current example of mine. Some bitch dies... And it's all eh who cares was a shit characters. But then you read up on it from back in the day and people were devastated. Cause they spent weeks and years with these people. Doesn't really matter in a binge marathon though.

2001 kept people interested cause there was an overall theme.
Heat... Same thing.
Good fellas.
Titanic.
Once upon a time...
Endgame (lousy example).
Casino.


If a movie draws you in... The length doesn't matter. In a theatre setting. People are focused on their phones. On current events. Twitter. Facebook. Hepra derpa shit. But a 3 hour movie that has pacing issues, drawn out story, laughable acting, cheap tech behind it... You can shout cliffhanger all you want... But if a movie is good and paced well from start to finish... People will watch it and not be bored or give up.

Scorsese has pacing issues in a lot of his movies. He draws shit out because that's what he's good at. It's not for current generation of streaming services. It's for theatres and a planned out movie night at home after buying a bluray. Not for streaming. Cause the attitude towards streaming is mostly background noise while we fidget on twitter, Myspace and ICQ.


Sin317 wrote:
I win, you lose. Or Go fuck yourself.
Back to top
The_Zeel




Posts: 14922

PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 22:50    Post subject:
Now I know what the pacing issues and bad editing in the movie reminded me of.
Your posts. Laughing

 Spoiler:
 
Back to top
StEFaN7




Posts: 6367
Location: them swamps
PostPosted: Sun, 8th Dec 2019 23:19    Post subject:
Laughing


I can see your soul at the edges of your eyes..
Back to top
WaldoJ
VIP Member



Posts: 32678

PostPosted: Mon, 9th Dec 2019 00:08    Post subject:
The_Zeel wrote:
Now I know what the pacing issues and bad editing in the movie reminded me of.
Your posts. Laughing

 Spoiler:
 


Just laik the movie was intended for on the go streaming. All my posts are done with autocorrect and fat fingers on a small keyboard on a shit android phone. Laughing


Sin317 wrote:
I win, you lose. Or Go fuck yourself.
Back to top
AmpegV4




Posts: 6247

PostPosted: Mon, 9th Dec 2019 01:22    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by AmpegV4 on Mon, 23rd Feb 2026 09:15; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Mister_s




Posts: 19862

PostPosted: Wed, 11th Dec 2019 13:07    Post subject:
It's a well made movie, but too long. 2.5 hours would've been enough. It was good seeing the old men together, but most disappointed me. It's probably the script or they're just too old, but the magic of dem olden days was not present (Pesci was weak for example). The highlight was Al Pacino for me, still vibrant.

7.5/10
Back to top
WaldoJ
VIP Member



Posts: 32678

PostPosted: Wed, 11th Dec 2019 14:00    Post subject:
AmpegV4 wrote:
I think Leo's earlier posts summed it up to be honest, it was a slow burn with heavy themes in age/mortality, i thought the deaging and using actors well into their twilight years was intentional and effective.

Only have to look at box office results to see what an average person thinks is good entertainment, There are adults that actually get excited about marvel and star wars movies/shows.


Nothing wrong with being a fan of pop culture.
Just cause you like star wars and mcu and dceu doesn't mean you can't appreciate the Irishman or legitimately good movies. Having a diverse joy in entertainment should not be an insult. I've met many people who force themselves to watch criterion collection movies as if it meant anything. Its real art. Real cinema. Kevin Smith is on that list. So is Tarantino. And a shit tonne of shit movies. Even shit eating movies. Just enjoy the entertainment. If you can't enjoy Irishman doesn't mean you're a dumb dumb. It just means it ain't for you. Forcing yourself to watch it, and be bored, and waste 3 hours of your life won't enlighten you if you're bored throughout. You won't even enjoy it. You'll just torture yourself just to believe you're not like everyone else. And you have class... It doesn't work that way.


Sin317 wrote:
I win, you lose. Or Go fuck yourself.
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Wed, 11th Dec 2019 14:09    Post subject:
WaldoJ wrote:
Nothing wrong with being a fan of pop culture.
Just cause you like star wars and mcu and dceu doesn't mean you can't appreciate the Irishman or legitimately good movies. Having a diverse joy in entertainment should not be an insult. I've met many people who force themselves to watch criterion collection movies as if it meant anything. Its real art. Real cinema. Kevin Smith is on that list. So is Tarantino. And a shit tonne of shit movies. Even shit eating movies. Just enjoy the entertainment. If you can't enjoy Irishman doesn't mean you're a dumb dumb. It just means it ain't for you. Forcing yourself to watch it, and be bored, and waste 3 hours of your life won't enlighten you if you're bored throughout. You won't even enjoy it. You'll just torture yourself just to believe you're not like everyone else. And you have class... It doesn't work that way.


Fuckin' PREACH Waldo, my dude! <3
Back to top
AmpegV4




Posts: 6247

PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 00:23    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by AmpegV4 on Mon, 23rd Feb 2026 09:15; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75740
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 00:53    Post subject:

This guy gets it.

But ...

Quote:
your not enjoying it

lol wut

Laughing


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75740
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 00:58    Post subject:
Kevin Smith is a moron. He used to be a likable moron, now he is just a plain moron. Just listen to him speak. Repeats the same shit over and over. He has two, maybe three, OK movies, the rest being complete shite. He hasn't done one good thing in decades. Yes, let's put him in the same "list" as Tarantino. lol wut And I am not a Tarantino fan.

I am not saying watch it just to fit in. Of course not. As I said, I haven't watched it either. I am just saying that I have found a pretty good correlation between people who do not enjoy the stuff I enjoy and my ability to tolerate them. Usually, I don't think they are very smart. Everyone does this in their head, but somehow people get offended when they are explicitly told what is in my head. I don't care about that. I am in a stage in my life where I don't coat my opinions with political correctness. Elitism is something to aspire to, not be ashamed of or be insulted by.

Derp derp, they are not dumb because they don't like some TV show or movie. I am just saying that a lot of "dumb dumbs" usually do not want to watch what I watch. That correlation I am free to make, and free to use when creating a social graph.


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
The_Zeel




Posts: 14922

PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 01:08    Post subject:
This reminds me of old IMDb threads...

Step 1: Enter thread of movie you haven't watched
Step 2: Post "I haven't seen X yet, but I can say with great confidence due to an elaborate study I conducted with a large pool of 3 people, that this movie yap yap yap..."
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75740
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 01:11    Post subject:
Say what you want, those boards had some of the most interesting discussions, with a lot of insider information. There hasn't been a real alternative to those. Some reddit topics get there, but usually it's just idiots yapping.


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
Morphineus
VIP Member



Posts: 24939
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 01:32    Post subject:
Oh man, I really do miss those IMDB boards. There was drivel in them... but fuck me, they also had really great threads with loads of information.

I used to go there on a daily basis, now I hardly even remember that place is still a thing. Though I did knew it was going to happen the moment they did away with the forums.

A great loss tbh. :/

Not even PtP has got anything like it.


Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75740
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 01:43    Post subject:
The boards were removed after some studios threatened to block access from IMDb Pro, after some movie got railed for being retarded, and of course official reasons were "basement dwellers misogyny/racism". Laughing


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
WaldoJ
VIP Member



Posts: 32678

PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 02:00    Post subject:
AmpegV4 wrote:
I think it only works in one direction, intelligent person can potentially enjoy something requiring virtually no brain compute (MCU, star wars, john wick etc). I don't believe the opposite is true, which is why we have to endure shit like:

- Movies shouldn't be 90mins even though people binge watch 956mins on Netflix.
- Particularly in "pop" culture movies, characters have to repeatedly tell you what you just watched in case you are too dumb to follow the non-existent plot.
- Sequel, Prequel, Reboot, Seboot, Middle Movie, This movie scraps movie 4-5 and sits after movie 3. This practice is entirely tailored for the dumb masses, marketing know dumb people will see and buy any piece of shit so long if it bares the name of something that was once good.

I fully agree with don't watch X, Y, Z if your not enjoying it, what kind of people actually do this?


Yes and no.
Mass produced bulk shit goes through testing to ensure even low iq will understand the plot and advertisers can safely advertise and throw money into the movie. Which is why everytime a cia agent, fbi agent, cop gets shot... There's a shot of a bulletproof vest. A lot of people are idiots. Especially those in focus groups. Especially those on boards who sign the cheques. They want media to be accessible and advertisable. But even high brow media is accessible and doesn't have to force feed you with shit.

Even then... Even a complete moron can read and understand some high brow content because they can relate. There are dumb asses who love godfather movies. Cause they're gangsta. But then they also love scarface. Which is shit Imo. There are some folks who like dog day afternoon. But then they also love Tarantino who is overrated Imo. But some folk see Tarantino movies as high class art. And very deep. Which to me is lol.

And mostly money talks. Latest terminator movie sucked. From the get go. You knew it would suck from the pre press saying men won't like it. Cool. It bombed.
So genre tailored movies of yore are pretty much gone. And now it's up to awesomeo5000 to sell tickets. Cause media is dying unless you're disney or warner brothers.


Sin317 wrote:
I win, you lose. Or Go fuck yourself.
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75740
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 02:04    Post subject:
@WaldoJ Agree on Scarface! Carlito's Way is the (much) better De Palma-Pacino collaboration. Smile


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8281
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Thu, 12th Dec 2019 12:15    Post subject:
Movie was way too long, and it was kinda hard to follow the timeline, with de-aged De Niro looking exactly the same in his 20s(??)/30s as in his 50s. I really wish they used younger actors.

Apart from that, a solid movie, well made and acted. But it's not as vibrant and gripping as Casino & Goodfellas. The soundtrack could have been a lot better too, it misses an iconic song/scene (like Ray Liotta entering the restaurant with 'Then He Kissed Me' playing).
It feels as if the age of the main actors also hurt the pace of certain scenes (the fight scene, obviously), but also the overall story. Except for Al Pacino Very Happy at 79, he's the oldest of the 3, but he actually sold his de-aged version. What an energy!
Back to top
monk3ybusin3ss




Posts: 11153

PostPosted: Thu, 30th Jan 2020 02:44    Post subject:
Back to top
Breezer_




Posts: 10909
Location: Finland
PostPosted: Tue, 25th Aug 2020 17:06    Post subject:
Back to top
Areius




Posts: 14845

PostPosted: Tue, 25th Aug 2020 17:14    Post subject: *****
*****


Last edited by Areius on Fri, 19th Sep 2025 16:26; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
bringiton




Posts: 4020

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Aug 2020 11:29    Post subject:
Areius wrote:
Original looked like shit but deepfake looks even worse.

Thing is, deepfake was made using a free software and the deaging in the movie cost like what, a few dozen million at least? They should have thrown that money at some proper deepfake development and ressources instead.


“The only way to deal with an unfree world is to become so absolutely free that your very existence is an act of rebellion.”
- Albert Camus
Back to top
Page 4 of 4 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Movie & TV Sparks Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group