If anything, cancel culture (historically and pre-internet) is originally sourced from conservativism to force the society to follow the normative ideals of the conservative society at the time. Being gay was illegal, children out of wedlock was very very very bad etc. etc. etc. etc. etc.... This new social shit media "cancel culture" is just a reactionary variant under a different name.
So to me cancel culture is neither left nor right, it's just a tool that is currently trending among nitwits going apeshit over anything that is seen as anti-progressive/anti-woke/anti-left/anti-whatever... It doesn't make it leftist (which is still a very blurry definition just like rightist is without any context or explanation what the "left" is to that person) in itself.
This is on point, "cancel culture" is just the "left"-side version of aggressive conservatism and purinatism, social and political matters are so much more organic than splitting things up into left/right side, as exemplified by Trump or populist ideologies in Italy/France (which casually mix aspects of socialism and far-right tropes in a populist cocktail) for instance.
Things are both a lot more nuanced, and yet much simpler than that. Yes, you could coin the term "cancel culture" for a certain recent trend which does primarly have to do with left-leaning people - but it's mainly a byproduct of social media and of very primitive human tendencies to me. Some will see a cultural crusade upon their beliefs, but I believe that to be the complaints of sore losers who can't see things will swing their side in some time - these are cyclical tendencies imo, progressive is currently more fashionable than conservative, but the wheel will keep spinning.
Stormwolf wrote:
Well, men will always be victims of women's schemes, sadly.
And women have never fallen victims to theirs !
Humans will always be victims of humans' schemes is a lot more like it, let's be real for a minute Agamemnon
R5 5600X - 3070FE - 16GB DDR4 3600 - Asus B550 TUF Gaming Plus - BeQuiet Straight Power 11 750W - Pure Base 500DX
Last edited by TheZor on Sun, 14th Feb 2021 10:03; edited 1 time in total
And no one has said otherwise, it just varies in intensity and that intensity has been turned up in the last few years (so much that we have given it a name, you can even say its a culture). Much of that is due to social media where people are 1) very outspoken 2) have ease of access to slander, lie, organize with similarly minded people for revenge, for cancelation. So in that sense Frant is absolutely right, but we can also look at who's doing it currently. That does not mean the Right is always saints and the left is always The Evil Empire. I was a leftist during the 90's, it was a much different movement than today.
I would say that the current version v60.3 (or something ) we call Cancel Culture started to get really big during Trump, many on the left were extremely angry and hungry for revenge. But again, not saying it's something completely new that we've never seen.
Last edited by vurt on Sun, 14th Feb 2021 13:27; edited 1 time in total
It's much more intense because we are much more divided than we've been for a long time. The signs of that are everywhere.
It's true that it's more visible due to internet, but it's also more intense due to internet / social media. There has never been a period during my life time (soon 50) where actors, teachers, union workers were cancelled due to political opinion. It's new (for me). Yes, I'm sure this can be different depending on where you live, but for the west in general the intensity is turned up something immensely in the last 4'ish years. I can not give 100's of examples from the 70's - 2016, no way... but i can absolutely do that for the last 4 years.
It's much more intense because we are much more divided than we've been for a long time. The signs of that are everywhere.
It's true that it's more visible due to internet, but it's also more intense due to internet / social media. There has never been a period during my life time (soon 50) where actors, teachers, union workers were cancelled due to political opinion. It's new (for me). Yes, I'm sure this can be different depending on where you live, but for the west in general the intensity is turned up something immensely in the last 4'ish years. I can not give 100's of examples from the 70's - 2016, no way... but i can absolutely do that for the last 4 years.
The big difference is that sin's examples are instigated by institutions, now the problem is the people themselves, and that is naturally much largr scale and much scarier.
Vigilante juatice is usually illegal, and that should go for internet shaming as well. Especially where no evidence can be provided
I can not give 100's of examples from the 70's - 2016, no way... but i can absolutely do that for the last 4 years.
Really? Did you miss the whole hippie movement of the 60's and late 70's? That was and entire fight like this about a shift in culture and outrage at late 50's racism and bigotry, at the marginalization and acceptance of blind eye business practices and capitalism, and pushes for "Like...Either change, or be changed out...man".
I can give some from the 80's and up. Not as old as you. Only 46. But I can think of TONS of times it was used: Black, Gays, Foreigners, or anything 'not fitting the current mindset'.
Many many situations of groups outing/firing/removing/ostracising someone for something they didn't 'like about them'. Sure it wasn't 100's of thousands at once doing it. But we didn't have a means to make it that many. But 30-100 can do just as much damage to someone locally or at a jobsite.
The difference? is we didn't have 50 24/7 news channels. 5000 websites for news, and 20 social media platforms for it to be 'todays' big news. You didn't hear about everyone of them thru some blurb feed, or mass spread of the situation in the blink of an eye like it can now.
To me your example is "I Dont remember it being so busy, and sooo much news going on back then. SO much shit happens now everyday", since back then was only 6pm and 11pm 30 minute local news, and one newspaper a day to get it from.
I think he sums it up well:
-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf
Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.
I remember a time when internet (and all it's forums and the new social platforms etc.) was lauded as a platform for freedom of speech, power to the people, finally something that let people be free of the shackles of governments. And now see where it's gotten us. We simply can't be trusted with such powerful tools; we turn it into shit and become more divided than ever instead of closer which is what everybody thought 15+ years ago. It's a sad reminder that humanity in general are assholes.
Whether it's a bunch of nutty flat earthers, rabid Trump supporters, extreme antifa nitwits, SJW's, snowflake knee jerk reactions, foreign manipulation using bot accounts to cause turmoil in a target country etc. it's clear that cultural changes are amplified a hundredfold on social media platforms. People become radicalized on social media platforms due to other people being skilled in manipulation and propaganda.
There is so much conflicting and conspiracy tinged stuff out there that people exist in a sea of confusion and fumble around for something to believe it. Once they've grabbed hold of something many will go into that idea/opinion/cause hardcore to feel stable and secure, turning nonsense into steadfast conviction.
Did I mention I hate twatter, fecebook, instafame etc.? Oh, right, I've mentioned it nearly every time I've written those names.
Yes, the far left. But not everyone on the left is far left? Or are they?
Its not left vs right.
Its the right opinion vs wrong opinion.
Thats it.
You have left leaning celebrities/people who get cancelled by the left. Not as much, but you do have a bunch.
The thing is right now on social media it is the left holds the right opinion. "Right side of history" etc etc. Fighting for the right values. Women's rights. Gay rights. Black rights. trans rights. You're seen as an asshole when you're seen fighting against these. Even when you're not.
But its not left vs right.
Its just most of the victims of cancel culture are right leaning. Their political affiliations add onto the fire since they branded every right leaning person a nazi. Thats all it is. Most woke people are liberals. Not all. But most. Most anti woke people are conservatives. Not all. But most.
But please stop bickering. It just gets heated when everyone is essentially saying the exact same thing just from their own perspective. If youre not willing to see and agree what the other side sees, you have no say in this argument.
You're looking at a spec of a bigger picture.
If you're arguing without seeing the bigger picture and ignoring what everyone is saying because it doesn't suit your own personal narrative you lost the fight. If you're getting triggered or post some idiotic comment how cancel culture is real because it happens without seeing how it happens. You lost the argument.
If Pedro posted what gina posted he'd be fine.
Because everyone is assuming Gina is a republican nazi who hates blacks, trans, gays, and women and she called all marginalized, oppressed people nazis. Even though she doesn't care who you are. And she was calling out the current state of society. Which is accurate in the online world.
She didn't get cancelled cause she posted the image. She got cancelled because people read into it and put their own spin on it and made it far worse and instead of people looking into it, they took it at face value and labeled her a bigot who compared gays, blacks, and trans to nazis.
Thats current cancel culture. People don't research. They don't look into things and blindly believe others.
@WaldoJ
While I do agree her outlook was an observation of comparison.
You cannot (or at least I think) talk about nazi's and jews in a very public opinion [regardless of its context] while working for Disney and not expect something to happen to immediately try to distance themselves from connection to it.
I mean Disney has a very dotted past with that term from Walt Disney himself, they are trying really really hard to disconnect from those.
Am I saying its right? No. Just saying its expected.
-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf
Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.
@WaldoJ
While I do agree her outlook was an observation of comparison.
You cannot (or at least I think) talk about nazi's and jews in a very public opinion [regardless of its context] while working for Disney and not expect something to happen
Nothing happened when Pedro did it. And he made a post, not a lazy retweet like Carano did.
That's the thing, they're taking a political stance, it's ok to do it if you're on the far left, otherwise no - you're fired.
They're the worst hypocrites i've ever seen as a company.
And no, firing actors or union workers, teachers for political opinion, i don't think it was a thing in e.g the 70's and i don't think anyone can give similar examples like present.
The only thing "good" about it is that the left always eats their own, eventually. Just look at J. K. Rowling lol... fucking hilarious how that turned around when she said that genders exists. Directly got death threats, completely canceled by the left.
Last edited by vurt on Mon, 15th Feb 2021 07:54; edited 1 time in total
Nothing happened when Pedro did it. And he made a post, not a lazy retweet like Carano did.
I feel because like the video I posted, its purely a business decision.
They cannot afford to lose Pedro, Gina they can. Without Pedro there is no Mandalorian, getting rid of him requires replacing him, and thats a HUGE risk replacing main characters. Without Gina, its the same show minus a single supporting character.
They cannot afford to lose the show, they can afford to lose a character.
It's not Morally right. But its Mouse Money right.
Disney reacted as a business in its best interest to the loud idiots. Be mad at the loud idiots that made Disney have to make a financial choice to convey public compliance in the face of lost revenue. Not at Disney for having to do it.
Because honestly. After the shouting idiot crowd caused it...NO matter what Disney did (even if that's nothing at all) they would have one side or the other saying that choice was the wrong one. They simply went with the one that was least damaging to the consumer demographic, and most Disney Brand consistency choice.
vurt wrote:
And no, firing actors or union workers, teachers for political opinion, i don't think it was a thing in e.g the 70's and i don't think anyone can give similar examples like present.
Quite a few minor character actors stop getting work when they supported the Vietnam war publicly and there was outcry people didn't like that opinion. There was 4-5 soap opera actors late 70's early 80's that 'disappeared' off the show after showing support for President Carter (a decisive stance in early 80's republican centric America) and he lost to Reagan. Sure there was more, but I barely remember 'adult' shows from early 80's I just remember that because my grandmother was realllllly mad about it, and stopped watching.
And I know its antidotal, but I had a 6th grade history teacher that was her first year, get fired because she was black and included more historical context to slavery than the book had (it really skimmed over it). And parents mad, accusing her of having an agenda to recruit black children into black movements. Forcing a black principal to have to fire her. (and I went to a more than 1/2 black school).
-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf
Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.
Last edited by DXWarlock on Mon, 15th Feb 2021 08:51; edited 4 times in total
They can much more easily get rid of him than Gina. Mandalorian is a character who should wear his mask (Pedro doesn't want to, and Favreau have to deal with his demands which goes against what he wants to do). They already fucked that up with revealing his face too many times, never made it into something epic or at least interesting. S2 could have ended better with a first reveal of his face instead of his third or whatever it was. They can use his stunt actor (which i guess is mostly what they're using) and a voice actor with similar voice (that can be hard, but not impossible).
The twitter crowd that was pro firing Carano isn't as large as her fan base, no where near. I know twitter isn't the entire world, but they do seem to listen to the loud mouthed far left crazies on twitter a tad too much.. and Disney are not alone in doing that.
Even if cancel culture could be said to have existed in some form before it's no excuse in any way or something we should accept.
Last edited by vurt on Mon, 15th Feb 2021 08:56; edited 1 time in total
I don't think its as easy as you think.
Nonsensical loyalty to a main character extends to the actor. Cartoons have people stop watching if they change who does the voice anytime they do it they viewership goes down by a measurable amount, so more risk than that changing an actual actor playing a main character in a franchise universe they rabidly love.
Like my wife was a HUGE walking dead fan...like massive, there was rumors of changing out a few actors in it (Don't remember who) and she got pissed and said if they did she will stop watching. She grew attached to the actor while they was playing that character, as much as the character.
Why soap operas always brought back main character with the "Oh no your not dead!" plot, vs trying to replace them with someone else and a "Oh you aren't dead and had plastic surgery due to an horrible accident" vaguely similar looking actor, they realized it didn't work well. Rating of the 'replacement' was horrible most every time.
-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf
Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.
Last edited by DXWarlock on Mon, 15th Feb 2021 08:58; edited 1 time in total
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum