Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves (Film)
Page 2 of 2 Goto page Previous  1, 2
Stormwolf




Posts: 24746
Location: Norway
PostPosted: Sun, 26th Mar 2023 05:41    Post subject:
Not having high hopes. I'm kinda tired of the marvel esque humor. I'll watch it once it hits the 2rentz
Back to top
Ankh




Posts: 23605
Location: Trelleborg
PostPosted: Sun, 26th Mar 2023 14:52    Post subject:
Mikey5449 wrote:
I’ve not heard of that before but all we used was pencils and paper and imaginations. The latter is what made it so damn enjoyable. I could picture everything about what was going on and of course how my character looked haha.


I totally agree! THATS the kind of rpg i love doing. But it seems like nowadays everyone want it visualized on the table Sad


shitloads of new stuff in my pc. Cant keep track of it all.
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14910
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Fri, 31st Mar 2023 16:20    Post subject:
wow what do you know, seems quite good

Back to top
pho08




Posts: 2941

PostPosted: Fri, 31st Mar 2023 16:32    Post subject:
is this cinemas only or coming to stream as well today?
Back to top
headshot
VIP Member



Posts: 40605
Location: UK
PostPosted: Sat, 1st Apr 2023 15:23    Post subject:
There are some very mixed reviews for this one but Angry Joe gave it 10?!



Man the cartoon was such an integral part of my childhood So Much Win



May the NFOrce be with you always.
Back to top
DXWarlock
VIP Member



Posts: 12607
Location: Florida, USA
PostPosted: Sat, 1st Apr 2023 19:36    Post subject:
headshot wrote:
There are some very mixed reviews for this one but Angry Joe gave it 10?!

To be fair, the 1/2 of the view I watched so far, is him rating it as a fantasy movie, not as a D&D movie.
Is it a good action fantasy movie? Probably. Is it a good representation of the literal title of the movie? No idea joe skims over those parts. And those with him just mention 'thats a thing in it' and never talk about how well that thing is represented.
Sort of like reviewing a VERY VERY badly done Lord of the Rings movie as 10 because it has awesome action scenes, great story, and good visuals. But ignoring if it even has anything to do with Hobbit or LOTR itself.

His review parallels what I mentioned before about a hypothetical Halo movie:
It is a well made FPS based movie that really brings a sense of being in an FPS shooter to the screen. 10 out of 10 (But Halo itself? No they got part of it way wrong, or just did it poorly for Halo itself).

headshot wrote:
Man the cartoon was such an integral part of my childhood So Much Win

Same! The GM cartoon character is my avatar pic on Roll20 and Foundry forums (VTT softwares for playing table top over internet if anyone doesn't know)


-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf

Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14910
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sat, 1st Apr 2023 20:07    Post subject:
Supposedly they made the D&D part well, and the actors are either players themselves or part of getting the role was to play actual campaigns to understand lore etc.. tons of easter eggs for D&D players.

I doubt it's anything super special, but it seems to be a 7/10 movie at least which is very surprising.
Back to top
DXWarlock
VIP Member



Posts: 12607
Location: Florida, USA
PostPosted: Sat, 1st Apr 2023 20:32    Post subject:
Hopefully, as every trailer so far has 3/4 of the D&D stuff completely wrong. Fingers crossed its limited to mostly they stuff they have in the trailer.
Sorcerer talking with dead, Druid being a owlbear, Gelatinous cube outside in dry desert heat and sunlight (they vigorously avoid both), Themberchaud [the fat dragon] massively over done movement speed on ground. (That dragon has a realllllly slow speed: "He was barely able to walk; he was unable to fly, only hop and flap his wings helplessly like a chicken" He can be outran at a casual walking pace in game..part of his lore and 'thing' about him.)

And while I do agree with the cartoon parody above of "If I say its allowed, it's allowed" GM call. A movie should not assume the role of making that call for everyone watching that they would be OK with how they are totally changing the rules. You have WAY too wide of a range of players/GMs watching to make huge calls like that without pissing some off. At least doing RAW (rules as written) no one could disagree with how that's done on screen.

So I will wait until I can see it yar version, or someone makes a proper "Is it actually a good D&D movie" as I cannot find any reviews of how good of a D&D movie it is. Just how good it is as a fantasy action movie. And disappointingly any YT channels I watch with hosts I respect and admire as GM/advice/discussion of tabletop in general are either: quiet about it or just havent got around to make a video about it. Not sure which.


-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf

Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.


Last edited by DXWarlock on Sat, 1st Apr 2023 20:46; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14910
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sat, 1st Apr 2023 20:44    Post subject:
yeah people do mention they get some of it wrong. i posted a lengthy review above, and he knows his D&D and points out some flaws but also why he thinks it's pretty good (7/10)
Back to top
DXWarlock
VIP Member



Posts: 12607
Location: Florida, USA
PostPosted: Sat, 1st Apr 2023 20:56    Post subject:
Maybe it's the difference of why me/him/whoever would go see it?
I'd be going specifically to finally see an accurate D&D movie, after the decades of failed bad ones. Im there for the D&D part. The action, comedy, etc is just an emergent property of it being like a D&D session being played.

There is 101 fantasy action movies already. The thing that makes me want to go to a theater after 10+ years of not going to one, to see this particular movie would be the draw of seeing a visual representation on a massive screen like I am sitting in on a well known GM's session for 2 hours.
So to me it would be the same reason I would sit in on someone else's gaming session: To see D&D played. He could be the best damn narrative GM in the world, but if he's is just constantly doing it wrong Id leave with the thought: GREAT story teller, horrible GM.

Hopefully no one takes it as me being a pedantic prick (well anymore than usual). I think it boils down to the reason of wanting to see it:
-Some want to see an action fantasy adventure movie that nods at D&D and easter eggs of: OHH I know that! I like that I know that! A wink and nod at 'my kind'. (Easter eggs do nothing for me, they are the low hanging fruit of movie tools to me)
-Some want to see a D&D movie, and what happens in it is based around the antics that come up from the mechanics of the game like a real session is.


-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf

Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.
Back to top
headshot
VIP Member



Posts: 40605
Location: UK
PostPosted: Tue, 4th Apr 2023 01:30    Post subject:
Nostalgic cringe Very Happy



May the NFOrce be with you always.
Back to top
AKofC




Posts: 4359

PostPosted: Tue, 4th Apr 2023 02:23    Post subject:
Yeah. While I have no strong feelings regarding the film, I will say that if you're not going to actually stick with the lore then why bother calling it D&D? Just have your own fantasy setting that borrows heavily on D&D.

But I suppose executives are all about that brand recognition.


Gustave the Steel
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14910
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Tue, 4th Apr 2023 03:10    Post subject:
seems like they stick to the lore to 95%. my friend who's a huge d&d nerd just saw it, says it's great. you're never gonna get perfection out of anything, be it games or movies, most of them don't even stick to their own lore if you analyze all of it.

i liked that the actors had to play D&D (one of them was already very familiar with it and a player - the barbarian chick).

Probably going to see it later this week.
Back to top
Nodrim




Posts: 10263
Location: Romania
PostPosted: Tue, 4th Apr 2023 18:45    Post subject:
Back to top
JackQ
Non-expret in Derps lagunge



Posts: 14516
Location: Kibbutznik, Israel
PostPosted: Tue, 4th Apr 2023 21:30    Post subject:
Fun film, 7.5/10.


"Fuck Denuvo"

Your personal opinions != the rest of the forum
Back to top
DXWarlock
VIP Member



Posts: 12607
Location: Florida, USA
PostPosted: Tue, 4th Apr 2023 22:47    Post subject:
vurt wrote:
seems like they stick to the lore to 95%. my friend who's a huge d&d nerd just saw it, says it's great. you're never gonna get perfection out of anything, be it games or movies, most of them don't even stick to their own lore if you analyze all of it.

i liked that the actors had to play D&D (one of them was already very familiar with it and a player - the barbarian chick).

Probably going to see it later this week.

I should hold judgement until seeing it. Hopefully the trailers scenes of the lore is just misleading.

-They have the Red Wizards of Thay wrong (at least the order and divide they had, from Szass Tam in the Gates of Neverdeath module)
-Tolivast, the main red wizard it looks like anyway in the trailers, is a bit different in how she does things.
-And Themberchaud is way too active, nimble, and reactionary for who he is: He is a big, fat, lazy, entitled dragon that can barely move (A human can outwalk him). Not to mention it seems he's not even in the place his lore and entire existence of being is based around (Gracklstugh), where he is forced to fuel the dwarven furnace flames with his breath for which he's too fat to even be able leave: And now I am far too large to ever leave. Even if I tore the entire place down around me, I could not claw my way to the surface from here. Instead, I remain buried in a prison of my parents' making, far beneath a sky I've never seen.
And if he is in elsewhere, then the timeline is messed up, as he was in Gracklstugh (and long after) when Szass Tam usurped the Red Wizards. Unless they recon the lore to make the movie fit.


-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf

Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14910
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Tue, 4th Apr 2023 23:11    Post subject:
seems like super minor things. i'm a huge LOTR nerd and i love the movies even though they change a ton of stuff, not just what i would say are minor things.

each to his own though.
Back to top
monk3ybusin3ss




Posts: 11153

PostPosted: Tue, 2nd May 2023 11:08    Post subject:
Dungeons.&.Dragons.Honor.Among.Thieves.2023.2160p.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.Atmos.DoVi.HDR.H.265-APEX
Back to top
DXWarlock
VIP Member



Posts: 12607
Location: Florida, USA
PostPosted: Fri, 5th May 2023 14:16    Post subject:
Grabbed the yarr version last night and watched it over dinner.

Going to have to give it 3 ratings depending on why/who sees it.
As a current genre style (for better or worse) action/comedy movie: 7/10
As a movie overall: 5.5/10
As a D&D movie: 4/10

Could not stop thinking it written to mimic Guardians of the Galaxy, in fantasy times.

Story was OK. But they got the timeline, the lore, and the location of things wrong a lot. Along with the mechanics of how wild shape works, how wild magic works, attuning to an object, the way a wizard uses cleric spells, and combat with Themberchaud all wrong too.

- Humor was boilerplate hollywood zingers and 'characters quipping at each other and making snide comments = funnah' type stuff.
- Could reallllly do without beating that movie trope horse once again of 'nerdy loser that girl shuns/ignores/won't date, gets the hot girl in the end'. Can they make a movie WITHOUT this for once?
- The easter eggs. 3/4 of them they take time to call out "It's a so-and-so!". Could not watch it without constantly feeling the director was elbowing me going "eh?..EH? look a [insert monster here]" while smirking.They was not subtle or well deployed, if there was one the camera made SURE you noticed the detail of it being there, other than the 80's cartoon cast one that one was done well.

- The crystal clear ripoff of hulk smashing loki in the floor was painfully apparent and gimmicky to me and a bad choice for the climax ending scene.
- The paladin being wrote as a jab of how some newer GM's NPC party members are over the top, perfect, and just disappear when done with I feel was a 'punching low' effect. I think it was supposed to be we are laughing with you, when it came off as laughing at you. (And was quite an insufferable and flat NPC/character at that, which was also supposed to be a joke with, but came out as a joke at newer GMs)

Was an OK watch. Wouldn't pay to see it. Not much worth talking about with my friends that play tabletop. It's...a movie, I suppose. It was very: Take any generic action comedy in last 10 years, and replace characters and setting movie mad-lib script. Very safe fomulatic movie style.
Was a good movie compared to the other D&D movies, but that bar couldn't get lower to start with Razz


-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf

Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.
Back to top
DXWarlock
VIP Member



Posts: 12607
Location: Florida, USA
PostPosted: Fri, 5th May 2023 15:25    Post subject:
Like this..either they made the locations wrong, or just really wanted to shoehorn in that easter egg reference to Baldur's gate so they could shoehorn in the scene of being at baldur's gate.
Why would they leave the ice prison and go alllll the way to Baldur's gate [red] to travel north to neverwinter? [blue]. That's the wording she used "We will sail down to Baulders gate and travel north"
That is 1500 MILES extra travel.

 Spoiler:
 


-We don't control what happens to us in life, but we control how we respond to what happens in life.
-Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times. -G. Michael Hopf

Disclaimer: Post made by me are of my own creation. A delusional mind relayed in text form.
Back to top
Yuri




Posts: 11008

PostPosted: Sun, 7th May 2023 19:21    Post subject:
Rubbish writing, if someone told me it was an MCU film I'd have believed them. How does this writer duo keep getting employed? Hollylol sure does have low standards.

https://www.thewrap.com/john-francis-daley-jonathan-goldstein-paramount-deal-goldday-production-company/

Even got a first look deal and launched a production company



1 and 2 are still amazing.
Back to top
Page 2 of 2 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Movie & TV Sparks Goto page Previous  1, 2
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group