Udio is getting better and better. You can now upload your own audio and then let the AI add for example vocals to it, or remix it, add instruments to it, lengthen something, or turn it into a specific musical style.
I tried it on a short amen drum break (the actual sample can be heard in the outro)
there are no limits, you can upload a commercial song and let it have a go at it, turn it into a new song. This will get tricky when it comes to copyright, but i bet there will be an overall ban on most streaming sites when it comes to AI because so many artists are going to get butthurt. The usual outcry when something comes out that fundamentally changes how we make music. It'll go away over time.
I'm torn between Udio and Suno. if I could combine them it would be great
I'm subbed to both as one is better at some things than the other and vice versa. And what I like about one, I dislike about the other (and vice versa too).
“I’d rather have questions I can’t answer than answers I can’t question.“ Richard Feynman.
I've used both only briefly, i have maybe 2 hours with each.
I wonder if there will be a time where generative is the norm. I mean for most media stuff, big and small things are generated, or are completely made from scratch. Prerecorded / static is considered dull. Dull until it becomes... vintage, and we will love it all over again.
No idea who the vocals is, its what it made more for the genre/style prompt of Al Green.
I got maybe 20-30 hours playing around on each of Suno and Udio.
Udio is great for some things, but can get weird on genre or not 'quite' get it right. While Suno can nail mixing genres more into what I think it would be. Like Mixing: Viking Chant, War Drums, 90s Westcoast Rap, and New age into one song.
Suno usually nails what I expected in 2-3 generations. Udio after like 30 still was random stuff I was thinking: This doesnt really sound like any of those, much less a mix of them.
And sometime Udio just doesn't know and makes completely random genre stuff. One song (cant remember what fringe genres I asked it) but it made a sort of pop/techno/trance thing...when nothing I asked it was that. It was like "Fuck if I know buddy, here is what I default to"
For if it will be the norm: While not same-same, to me it sort of like a synth wall.
Most the time composers dont go in with a specific song to make, but a feel/vibe and aim towards it and go "ohh I like that" and evolve a song out of it. Same here (sort of) to me.
So if its a norm at some point, I dont see a huge issue with it. As its sort of the same line as long ago: synths will ruin 'true' talented musicians. Then: DAW will ruin the livelihood of live musicians.
You know the line of gate keeping thinking that pops up anytime something can be automated be it music on DAW's and synths, woodworking (CNC/laser), cooking, etc: Oh now it just 'push a button' and make stuff. But it never ruins a field, it adds to it.
Some people love/dont care if music is 100% sequencer generated music. Some people crave a person playing it. Same here to me. Those that want 'a soul of a person' behind what they listen to will continue to listen to human performers, those that just care about the music and not what makes it, will continue to not care the source, only the result.
Udio sounds better on vocals, sometimes Suno you can tell has that quantized/autotune generated sound. And at times repeats vocals from before in the song, or adds its own for some reason. Or just decide to reorder them or start on verse 2
While Udio is way better on your lyrics is what you get (usually), and done how you put them. I fight with it more understanding odd mixes of genres. Turning on 'custom mode' helps as with it off your genre/description is just a suggestion and it picks mix of 'like' genres each new generating.
Like telling it: 90's rap/hip hop, jazz, and gangster rap. It can return random ones like: Soul, R&B, and funk as the genre types it uses (which changes each time you generate) if you let it try to suggest ones to mix and match 'based on' what you told it.
Do you think it was different when Internet came? No. It was the same thing, every company leaned into Internet. You must do this to be relevant, this is just as big as when Internet was introduced. Of course it's a TON of BS, who cares if some boomers gets bullshitted about AI, clearly doesn't affect a single person on this forum, not even us who are almost-boomers
@vurt
I'm with you, I dont think its going away. its just pickup being pickup about a thing he dislikes: It will pop one day, and I've called it 47 times so far that 'Lawl it's happening" 48th time will be a charm!
Is it over hyped? Yea, any new tech marketing will be. Happens in everything not just internet/tech space: Gluten a new hot thing to talk about? Start labeling shit that never had gluten in it, as gluten free. (the 80's) Leather plush seats all the rage in cars? Everyone and thier brother now advertise the vinyl seats they always had as : Corinthian leather [IE fake leather]
Y2K coming? Slap "Y2K ready!", on computers that was already fine. Marketing.
Same here, hype will die down, but technology will stay. Its too impactful for actual non-trivial uses outside of "Talk to a bot" shit. Like Medical research, engineering design, simulations for testing, etc. To fade away. It will be less a in your face "It has AI!" and more a tool used just as much as the in your face thing, just commonplace and not hyped as part of the thing anymore.
I feel the people that say its a fade, only know of the fade uses of it, which is like 5% of the total usage of it across all sorts of fields. And saying it will die down.. sure it will I agree, that 5% you are aware, of will (Which is 100% of what you are aware of, so 100% of what you see will peter out one day).
The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
Y2K coming? Slap "Y2K ready!", on computers that was already fine. Marketing.
Same here, hype will die down, but technology will stay. Its too impactful for actual non-trivial uses outside of "Talk to a bot" shit. Like Medical research, engineering design, simulations for testing, etc. To fade away. It will be less a in your face "It has AI!"
Exactly.
Damn, i've forgotten about the "Y2K ready!" haha! I remember i called that shit out.
Didn't know you could ask it about a username, i tried on myself "who is vurt the modder?"
Spoiler:
"Vurt is a well-known modder in the gaming community, particularly famous for his contributions to the modding scenes of games like "The Elder Scrolls" series (e.g., Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim) and other popular RPGs. He is renowned for creating high-quality texture packs, environmental enhancements, and other mods that significantly improve the visual and atmospheric aspects of these games.
Some of Vurt's most notable works include:
Morrowind Overhaul - Sounds & Graphics: A comprehensive mod that overhauls the graphics and sounds of "The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind", making the game look and feel more modern while preserving its original charm.
Skyrim Flora Overhaul: This mod enhances the flora in "The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim", adding new trees, grasses, and other plants to create a more lush and immersive environment.
Vurt's Groundcover: This mod for "Morrowind" adds various types of ground cover, such as grass and small plants, to the game's landscapes, greatly enhancing its visual appeal.
Vurt's Solstheim Tree Replacer: Another "Morrowind" mod, this one specifically improves the trees in the Solstheim region, making them more detailed and visually pleasing.
Vurt's mods are highly regarded for their quality and attention to detail, often becoming essential additions for players looking to enhance their gaming experience. If you are interested in his work, you can find his mods on various modding websites like Nexus Mods and Mod DB."
Pretty accurate apart from "Morrowind Overhaul - Sounds & Graphics" which isn't even my mod i did contribute at some point to it i guess.
retarded. his point is stupid too, no one is saying real photo is dead just because there's image synthesis. it's like trying to prove some stupid point that acoustic instruments might no longer have a place because there are synths/sample players that can replicate them. real photos will always have a place, just like real instruments.
cheating in contests = fraud, hope they'll let him pay up.
I don't get his point either. That taking pictures of real things still equals its a photo of a real thing and viable as a photo?
Who doesn't think 'real' things will ever have a place? Pedigree and subject still does, and always will hold a place in our psyche. It's why a real autograph costs more than a fake, or a replica car is far cheaper than a real one.
Both can look exactly like the real thing, indistinguishable from an authentic one. Why makes it different? The knowledge of where it came from, thats it. That it is the 'real thing'.
I can buy a fake Mona Lisa. Doesn't mean that the real one isn't coveted 1000 times more.
Let us get star trek replication tech, and can make anything artificially. Some people will stay pay exponentially more for the real things. People somewhere: Replicate a perfect 1967 mustang? No thanks I want a 'real' one.
for the most part it looks better, tiny details can be worse, like if you pause and zoom in, but who watches a movie like that. i mean you can make fun of grainy in the same way and saying "look! this grainy face is ruining the movie for me!"
that being said, it will age terribly because it gets better like every 6 months.
it's not "ruining" anything though, you can still watch your grainy movie, if you prefer that, or you can wait and give another AI restoration a shot in 5 years or whatever, it'll have improved x10 or more in that time.
I think restoring super old footage (70 or so years) can be interesting, restoring Aliens, Bladerunner, i really have very little interest in it, i like the original movies as they are.
I concluded that the best shot at accelerating AI and generally tech utopian visions in the US (and by extension in the west) is not with the democrats anymore, but the republicans.
More generally - center right to right, hard centrists and libertarians but definitely NOT anything close to the left wing.
Maybe that also explains Musk backing Trump now, it all makes sense:
The whole decel and degrowth movements and AI critics are gonna use the DEI, "AI ethics" and climate change arguments to sabotage progress wherever they can.
This mostly resonates on the left and it has already begun. They will try to stop it, try to regulate it to death.
I still can't believe the conservative, god fearing and job loving morons are the best shot we got.
But the tech billionaires are going to play them like a fiddle. Time to switch sides.
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum