|
|
| Page 2 of 2 |
Parallax_
VIP Member
Posts: 6422
Location: Norway
|
Posted: Fri, 26th Jan 2007 13:34 Post subject: |
|
 |
I found the story in the Illusionist to be horribly bad. Your standard love crapola story smudged in an unoriginal plot twist. Not to mention Jessica Biel'a'crapola. Very few of the actors actually managed to speak the correct accent. And I love Norton, but he might have been a misscast in this movie. Spoiler: | Giamatti standing there figuring in all out like he was having an orgasm was hilarious as well. |
Sorry, but to me they are not comparable.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
chiv
Posts: 27530
Location: Behind You...
|
Posted: Fri, 26th Jan 2007 23:40 Post subject: |
|
 |
im actually getting somewhat sick of twist endings... illusionist really pushed me over the edge... these days EVERY film has a twist... it feels lazy actually... films cant stand on their own merit when they tell a story, they need to rely on some 'clever' twist at the end so that they seem deeper and more intelligent than they really are.... i liked the illusionist, but it felt really lazy to be honest... you cant directly compare illusionist and prestige ('magic' is their only joining feature but its pretty flimsy) - out of the two, prestige was definately superior... the story was far more clever.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 27th Jan 2007 01:24 Post subject: |
|
 |
Well, the Prestige has twists through the entire movie. So if it wouldn't have had a twist ending, it would just feel awfully wrong.
One interesting thing about this is that different viewers will support one of the two different characters. When I came out of the cinema, my mate asked me who I wanted to" win", and at first, I thought it was a dumb question (Bale's character of course!), but then I realised that I mostly just thought this because I'm horribly Bale-biased. Credit to the writers and actors for this.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
chiv
Posts: 27530
Location: Behind You...
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 27th Jan 2007 14:45 Post subject: |
|
 |
| towelie_swe wrote: | Well, the Prestige has twists through the entire movie.
|
No, not really. Unless you call "more of the same" a twist.
| Quote: |
One interesting thing about this is that different viewers will support one of the two different characters. When I came out of the cinema, my mate asked me who I wanted to" win", and at first, I thought it was a dumb question (Bale's character of course!), but then I realised that I mostly just thought this because I'm horribly Bale-biased. Credit to the writers and actors for this. |
I didn't really care for anyone of them.
And yes, people who like this movie are so blinded by their love for the actor's they fail to see the horrible story.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
chiv
Posts: 27530
Location: Behind You...
|
Posted: Sat, 27th Jan 2007 18:45 Post subject: |
|
 |
how is the story horrible? its a story of oneupmanship and ego, blinded by their goals they lose everything... it a far more satisfying story than the other 50 or so 'major' films last year...
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
WaldoJ
VIP Member
Posts: 32678
|
Posted: Sat, 27th Jan 2007 18:48 Post subject: |
|
 |
Wolverine is a real vile character. 
| Sin317 wrote: | | I win, you lose. Or Go fuck yourself. |
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sat, 27th Jan 2007 20:41 Post subject: |
|
 |
| chiv wrote: | | how is the story horrible? its a story of oneupmanship and ego, blinded by their goals they lose everything... it a far more satisfying story than the other 50 or so 'major' films last year... |
Yes, oneupmanship and ego is exactly what the plot is about. Too bad that's all this movie has to offer, except for a silly "plot twist":
Spoiler: |
zOmg! I can clone people!
zOmg! My twin cut his fingers off!
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sun, 28th Jan 2007 02:08 Post subject: |
|
 |
Well, this movie was definately better and more worth watching than most other Hollywood productions... Something different from the same schematics they use all the time...
“The only way to deal with an unfree world is to become so absolutely free that your very existence is an act of rebellion.”
- Albert Camus
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sun, 28th Jan 2007 04:07 Post subject: |
|
 |
| dominae wrote: | | chiv wrote: | | how is the story horrible? its a story of oneupmanship and ego, blinded by their goals they lose everything... it a far more satisfying story than the other 50 or so 'major' films last year... |
Yes, oneupmanship and ego is exactly what the plot is about. Too bad that's all this movie has to offer, except for a silly "plot twist":
Spoiler: |
zOmg! I can clone people!
zOmg! My twin cut his fingers off!
|
|
Okay buddy, tell us what made The Illusionist so great? ...Also, what would've made The Prestige better? If not for the twists it had, what would you have done as the writer of the script and/or the director? Your argument of the story being boring and stupid makes absolutely no sense. You're just saying it is because you think so. ...and don't tell me you think a story about revenge, obsession and ego is less "good" than one about absurd illusions and love. Most people who know literature and film well will agree that the main idea and plot of The Illusionist is quite unoriginal. It was basically a common story done in a very refreshing way I find. The Prestige, on the other hand, is not comparable to many other films or tales for that matter and furthermore, had wonderful acting, mystery and yes, twists that kept everyone guessing, puzzling over the story and actually talking about and trying to figure out the fine details and meaning of the movie after they left the theater. All that is very hard to find in one film and thus gives The Prestige great value as a film. Of course movie quality is subjective, but only to a certain point - not entirely. If you, say, went to University to study film or creative writing for 4 years and then provided some logical, proper reasons for why you thought the movie was bad, then maybe you'd have some value and validity in your opinion. Otherwise, just stop wasting your time posting in this thread. Generally, if you're the only one arguing the negative, the burden of proof and convincing is on you. If you'd rather just spout your personal opinion merely to attract attention and find argument in others, you should stop as it is pathetic.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sun, 28th Jan 2007 05:16 Post subject: |
|
 |
well this movie was like this

|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
Posted: Sun, 28th Jan 2007 14:03 Post subject: |
|
 |
| illz55 wrote: |
Okay buddy, tell us what made The Illusionist so great?
|
Nah, because I already know you will disagree.
| Quote: |
...Also, what would've made The Prestige better? If not for the twists it had, what would you have done as the writer of the script and/or the director? Your argument of the story being boring and stupid makes absolutely no sense.
|
Yes it does, because nothing that drives the plot happens. I'm about as interested in the two rival magicians and their respective agendas as I am interested in Slobodan in Moscow.
It felt more like a documentary than anything else.
| Quote: |
You're just saying it is because you think so.
|
No shit Sherlock?
| Quote: |
...and don't tell me you think a story about revenge, obsession and ego is less "good" than one about absurd illusions and love.
|
Revenge, obsession and ego can be portrayed in millions of ways, the way it's portrayed in this movie is rather dull, unimaginative and repetetive. There is no real suspense, no real effort to involve the audience in the character's conflict. "Things" just happen, the story could've been so much more engaging. Instead they put a camera in front of paint drying, and hope the great actors will solve things.
I get it that you can be so biased by a character so you can forgive him for anything, even be convinced that a horrible movie he's in is awesome because he was in it. I get that, because it's happened to me. But this is such a horrible story.
They had everything, actor capacity, awesome props, tremendous budget. And a script and a director that was shite.
| Quote: |
Most people who know literature and film well will agree that the main idea and plot of The Illusionist is quite unoriginal. It was basically a common story done in a very refreshing way I find. |
The Illusionist is a cliché, yes. Very much so. But there's a reason why people like clichés. There's a reason why something becomes one.
Illusionist isn't necessarily an awesome movie, it's just an example of how you can add suspense and involve the audience.
In the illusionist you actually involve yourself. With The Prestige you watch two people who act irrational to the point the storyteller makes it so you can no longer suspend disbelief, and just go "boring, why should I even care about these people?"
I liked Tesla, I had some empathy from him. But he was hardly a main character... Prestige lacks focus.
| Quote: |
The Prestige, on the other hand, is not comparable to many other films
|
Yes it is. There are droves of films out there about rivalry, competition, and ego driving. You should watch more films if you think is something unique. Because it clearly isn't.
A for effort, F for execution.
| Quote: | | [...]wonderful acting[...] |
Yes. Agreed. Awesome actors, and they depicted their roles quite well.
| Quote: |
[..] mystery and yes, twists that kept everyone guessing, puzzling over the story and actually talking about and trying to figure out the fine details and meaning of the movie after they left the theater. |
Where you see mystery, I see very little subtext. It's a very basic conflict story, illustrated so poorly, it can't be saved by even by Christian Bale, who's got a spotless movie record in the past.
Where you see twists, I see simple causality. The fact they added
Spoiler: |
Cloned men, and a twin
|
doesn't save the plot.
| Quote: |
All that is very hard to find in one film and thus gives The Prestige great value as a film. Of course movie quality is subjective, but only to a certain point - not entirely. If you, say, went to University to study film or creative writing for 4 years and then provided some logical, proper reasons for why you thought the movie was bad, then maybe you'd have some value and validity in your opinion. Otherwise, just stop wasting your time posting in this thread. Generally, if you're the only one arguing the negative, the burden of proof and convincing is on you. If you'd rather just spout your personal opinion merely to attract attention and find argument in others, you should stop as it is pathetic. |
Ahh, so everyone who havent' studid film or creative writing for 4 years have no validity in their opinion.
So much for your ability to argue.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Parallax_
VIP Member
Posts: 6422
Location: Norway
|
Posted: Sun, 28th Jan 2007 15:15 Post subject: |
|
 |
Bla Bla Bla 
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Posts: 3074
Location: San Diego, CA
|
Posted: Sun, 28th Jan 2007 16:22 Post subject: |
|
 |
prestige > illusionist
by far
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Posts: 3074
Location: San Diego, CA
|
Posted: Sun, 28th Jan 2007 16:42 Post subject: |
|
 |
im not trying to argue with you, its my opinion, just how u say u think prestige is bad is yours. jeez fuck off this thread loserface
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
WaldoJ
VIP Member
Posts: 32678
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fraich3
Posts: 2907
Location: Not from my mouth!
|
Posted: Sun, 28th Jan 2007 19:10 Post subject: |
|
 |
| WaldoJ wrote: | dominae... one sec.
Spoiler: | you think that was his twin? That was his clone!!  |
|
Hmm, I am intrigued. Care to explain a little more, cause if been thinking around some of the same angles.
"Zipfero is the biggest fucking golddigger ever" - Mutantius
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Parallax_
VIP Member
Posts: 6422
Location: Norway
|
Posted: Sun, 28th Jan 2007 21:49 Post subject: |
|
 |
| dominae wrote: | Well, with such convincing arguments, you are both probably right. I now see the error in my ways. And shall repent by murdering all the children.  |
No need to elaborate anymore. Difference of opinion that's all.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Ispep
VIP Member
Posts: 4117
|
Posted: Mon, 29th Jan 2007 00:20 Post subject: |
|
 |
"Watching The Prestige is like observing a magic act where the magician's sleight-of-hand isn't deft enough. The trick almost works, but not quite… With its mechanical twists and turns and lack of heart, the movie often resembles Sleuth in superficial ways, except The Prestige resorts to cheating while Sleuth relied on cunning and guile. As is too often the case with narratives that try to be oblique to the end, the film's climax is strangely predictable. The Prestige goes to a great deal of trouble - including a triple time-line - to protect secrets that aren't all that surprising or hard to guess."
"With a pedigree as splendid as the one behind The Prestige, the movie's inability to captivate consistently must be considered a disappointment. [...] While one could argue that both films telegraph their third-act surprises, The Illusionist is less ponderous and more enjoyable."
"The Prestige is too well made to be considered "bad," but it fails to deliver in ways that will earn it more shrugs than raves. There's nothing wrong on the acting front: headliners Hugh Jackman and Christian Bale are at the tops of their games as rival magicians caught in the grip of an obsession to defeat one another. Michael Caine is delightful in a supporting role."
"As for the explanation at the end…yes, it's one of those instances in which a guy holding a gun provides a blow-by-blow account more for the benefit of the audience than the other character. [...] The title is explained as being one of three steps in a trick: the pledge, the turn, and the prestige. Oddly, it's that third act, the prestige, where this film is found lacking. There's plenty going on but never any real magic."
Just some excerpts from a review I felt expressed much of how I felt when I watched the film. It was well worth a watch and the acting is top notch (Scarlett excepted) but it's nothing profound or worthy of the adulation some are expressing in this thread.

|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
| Page 2 of 2 |
All times are GMT + 1 Hour |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
|
|
 |
|